H
R&D Needs for the Power Delivery System
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
System components that are less vulnerable to incursion, gun shots, or explosive devices | Physically robust towers, insulators, and conductors Physically robust transformers, breakers, and switchgears Low-cost undergrounding techniques |
X X | X X X |
|
New techniques for reducing stress by improving operation and maintenance | Integrated asset management |
| X | |
New monitoring and diagnostic techniques to reduce the impact of attacks and improve reliability | Non-intrusive monitoring Non-destructive evaluation Low-cost dissolved gas analyzers | X X X | ||
Physically protective shields for substations and transformers | Advanced materials for shielding | X |
|
|
Recovery equipment (to recover from attacks) | Substation recovery (temporary) transformers Recovery breakers |
|
| X X |
Advanced protection devices to mitigate outages from attacks | Self-programming power electronic relays |
| X | X |
Sensors and communication to increase monitoring, mitigate outages, and enhance response | Wide-area measurement Dynamic thermal circuit rating Video sag monitoring Integrated electricity and communication system architecture Precision high-speed time-stamped monitoring Enhanced visualization |
| X X X X X X | X X X X X X |
Computational ability to monitor systems, mitigate outages, and better plan restoration | Topology estimating CAR monitoring [Truly] real-time analysis Integrated engineering and economic methodology for power system operation Market simulation Fast simulation and modeling Advanced training simulators Advanced date storage, management, and incident reconstruction |
| X X X X
X X X X |
X
|
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| Passive technology to increase power flow on existing rights of way to reduce the potential impact of events | Reconfiguring (new bundles, higher voltages, etc.)High-amperage conductors High-temperature superconducting cables Composite structures | X X X X | X X X X | |
Short-circuit current limiters to reduce the possibility of cascading outages | Power electronics based | X | X | |
Enhanced control of the existing system to reduce vulnerability and enhance recovery | Reducing the cost of current-generation FACTS devices Voltage-source converters Asynchronous rotating machines Advanced systems control | X | X | |
Developing software that thwarts cyber attacks | Hardening energy management systems against cyber attacks | X | ||
TABLE H.2 Research Area Options for Enabling New Bulk Power (Transmission) System Architecture
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| Technologies to enable complete control of the power system to mitigate outages and enhance restoration | Advanced power electronic devices Advanced DC back-to-back Low-cost FACTSPower electronic breakers Intelligent universal substation transformers Multi-layered control strategies Distributed autonomous agents Integrated control strategies Complete system automation Self-healing topology Object models for all digital devices | X X X X X X X X X X | X X X X X X X X | |
Technologies to enable smaller synchronous or DC systems to operate in an integrated fashion so as to reduce system vulnerability | Microgrids | X | X | |
Technologies to greatly increase power flow to reduce stress and mitigate outages | AC superconducting cables | X | ||
Innovative computational ability technologies | Fast modeling and simulation | X |
| |
TABLE H.3 Research Area Options Primarily for Existing Distribution System Architecture
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| Asset management to reduce system stress | Integrated asset management Tighter voltage control Monitoring of capacitor banks | X X X | ||
Increased power flow to reduce stress on the system | Reconfiguring and increasing voltage |
| X |
|
Improved reliability and system vulnerability | Reducing underground construction costs | X | ||
Enhanced control to reduce stress and enhance restoration | Power electronics network protectors | X | X | |
Reconfigured network grids in large cities | Submersible fast switches | X | X | X |
TABLE H.4 Research Area Options for Enabling New Distribution System Architecture
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| Advanced distribution automation (DA) | Advanced DA architecture Object models for all digital distribution devices Fault anticipator Intelligent universal transformer | X X X X | X | |
Power electronics technologies to manage demand and improve reliability | Inductive (contactless) charging | X |
| |
Distributed energy resources | Integration of distributed energy resources | X | X | |
Distributed generation technologies | Photovoltaics | X | X | |
Electric energy storage devices | Lead acid battery | X | X | |
Communication technologies | Broadband over power line | X | X | |
Technologies to enhance control | Power electronic breakers | X | X | |
TABLE H.5 Research Area Options Primarily for Existing Device and Building Systems
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| High-efficiency lighting systems | Photoluminescence material Daylight harvesting Integrated lighting High-intensity discharge Advanced fluorescent lamp systems Light-emitting diodes | X X X X X X | ||
High-efficiency motors and motor drives | Soft-switching adjustable speed drives | X | ||
High-efficiency space conditioning | Water loop heat pumps | X | ||
High-efficiency water heating | Heat pump water heaters Heat recovery water heaters | X | ||
High-efficiency refrigeration | High COP refrigeration system | X | ||
Efficiency industrial electrotechnologies | Infrared heating devices | X | ||
Building systems technologies to reduce demand and consumption | Smart thermostats | X | X | |
TABLE H.6 Research Area Options for Enabling New Device and Building Systems Architecture
| Technology/Operational Strategy Application | Research Areas | Objectives | ||
| Thwart Attack | Reduce Vulnerability | Reduce Impact | ||
| Technologies to integrate end-use devices and buildings into the power delivery system | Consumer portal Smart appliances and devices Power quality monitoring Automated meter reading Outage monitoring Energy management system integration Advanced demand response Smart meters | X X X X X X X X | X X X X X X | |
Technologies to enable buildings to operate independently | Low-cost power conditioning | X |
| |