During Task 6, the project team used a SUM typology to produce six case studies for the project report. The project team developed the interview guide used for data collection in the Task 5 stakeholder interviews and well as the Task 6 case studies work for the project. For the case studies, more specific topical probing was used with the interview guide to dig into more detailed information about case study sites/services selected while also (in some cases) talking to additional program/service partners. The project team completed the Institutional Review Board process for approval of this information collection.
The project team invited multiple stakeholders to the case study call discussions at the concurrence of the primary agency/organization at the center of the study; this included public sector, private sector, and nonprofit/social service agencies involved with the service/program (either formally or informally). The interview guide is included in Appendix B of this report.
The case studies included in this section document information about the service/program in each location and address the following topics as information is available:
The case studies in this section of the report are:
Shift Bike is an electric bikeshare program available in Eagle County, CO, in a set of neighboring communities: Town of Vail, Town of Avon, Communities of EagleVail, and Edwards. The Town of Vail is the lead public organization for the program in providing oversight and administration, but all partner communities coordinate with the turnkey vendor, which provides the e-bikes, software, and operational support. Shift Bike provides an interesting example of a hub-based bikeshare using e-bikes, connections between periphery areas and local downtowns, and seasonal variability in trip demand and weather effects on operations. The program is highlighted here as a case study due to the lead organization’s integration with other partner communities and work in regional coordination on a micromobility solution in a more rural area.
Shift Bike began in 2020 as a small pilot program in the Town of Vail using $25,000 from the town’s operating budget; this funding came from the local real estate transfer tax, which supports all sustainability program initiatives. Vail partnered with a technology program for an initial three-month program, using 12 e-bikes at six stations. This iteration of bikeshare was station-based and required electrified stations for the e-bikes to recharge. As use of the program was proven, the Vail Town Council committed resources toward the program expansion.
In 2022, Vail partnered with Avon and EagleVail to jointly issue an RFP for regional electric bikeshare service. This effort formed from a local transportation working group (which included a micromobility subcommittee) among the Eagle County Climate Action Collaborative, which shared insights from Vail’s previous pilot and discussed community needs and service goals together (Longwell, 2022). This regional coordination approach provided the benefit of partners being able to go after higher levels of grant funding when teamed together. Proposals responding to the RFP were jointly evaluated by the three partners.
The program was rebranded as Shift Bike, continuing to operate as a turnkey system model with the vendor handling all operations aspects, while the Town of Vail provides oversight and administration for the regional system. Under the selected vendor (Drop Mobility), the e-bikes use detachable batteries so that the vendor operations staff can quickly swap them out and stations are not required to be electrified. In 2022, Shift Bike had 90 e-bikes and 20 stations. Subsequently, Eagle County and Edwards Metro District joined the program as well, for further expansion.
By June 2023, Shift Bike increased to 155 bikes and 32 stations; bikes and stations were distributed proportionally between the member communities, according to funding allocations from each member (Deck, 2023). Vail has around half the stations and bikes for the system, Avon has around a third, and EagleVail and Edwards the remainder, per an intergovernmental agreement (IGA). The hub-based model for Shift Bike allows for designated bike locking locations to be changed rather than permanently located at fixed stations, should a member committee dedicate to change a location later on.
The technology for Shift Bike is proprietary software owned by the vendor, who provides a customer-facing smartphone app for users to check out e-bikes and an online dashboard for member communities’ staff to view real-time information on the program.
The program is designed as a hub-based model with a defined geofenced area. Currently, the software platform does not have integrations with other transportation or fare payment options, but the vendor notes that such integrations are possible through APIs.
Shift Bike uses electric-assist e-bikes to help riders while pedaling during travel. With the current Shift Bike program, the vendor addressed electrification, charging, and flat tire issues by using bikes with swappable batteries and solid foam tires so that bikes do not have to go out of service. The e-bikes can reach speeds up to 16 mph on a full electric charge lasting between 30–40 miles; the bikes must be returned to a designated Shift Bike geofenced station at the end of the ride (Longwell, 2022).
Currently, formal partners with the vendor for the Shift Bike program include the Town of Vail, Town of Avon, EagleVail Metro District, Eagle County Government, and Edwards Metro District (RealVail, 2023). Each municipality partner has a separate contract with the vendor, meaning there are four contracts for each partner’s respective portion of the system and funding contributions. Eagle County’s contract includes Edwards Metro District’s portion of their contribution (which Eagle County then invoices to Edwards). The reasoning for separate agreements is to allow for each member to handle invoicing and other requirements related to grant funding awarded to support the program. Each contract has nearly identical or similar language, with some specific tailoring for local attorney requirements as well as specific station and e-bike counts for the particular community member in the given agreement. The partners and vendor have bi-weekly check-in meetings to monitor performance of the program and discuss any issues.
The municipal partners note that this process would be easier if there was a single entity that signed one overall agreement with the vendor and handled the invoicing and payments processes. There is a possibility that in the near future a regional transportation authority (RTA) for Eagle County will be formed; this would provide an opportunity for the RTA to assume leadership of the Shift Bike program and work with the vendor under a single agreement.
As of 2023, there is also an IGA between the Town of Vail, Town of Avon, Eagle County, and EagleVail Metro District used to specify the Shift Bike expansion terms and roles between the partners. One continual challenge is with grant funding for the program and dispersing the funding fairly between members; the IGA helps specify these funding allocations from the grant award while the Town of Vail handles the administration of the funding. The IGA arrangement also enables the region to get more funding for the Shift Bike program together through the larger collective size of the members.
The Town of Vail is the lead municipality for administration of the Shift Bike program. Within the town government, the Environmental Sustainability Department (ESD) is the lead for Shift Bike and other micromobility related projects. ESD also conducts work in areas of waste management, sustainable business programs, and climate and greenhouse gas inventories. In addition to Shift Bike administration and coordination, ESD leads the E-bike for Essentials program. This initiative is a program for essential workers to own a bicycle (around 6–8 bikes are in use currently); select residents in the program must be income qualified. For Shift Bike, Vail leads communication with the vendor (Drop Mobility) and is the lead agency for the IGA and grant funding awards.
The Town of Avon is a member municipality of the Shift Bike program since 2022. The Transit Department within the town government leads their communication and coordination efforts related to Shift Bike.
The EagleVail Metro District is a member municipality of the Shift Bike program, also joining the collaborative in 2022.
The Edwards Metro District is a member of the Shift Bike program for hub locations within Edwards, joining the collaborative in 2023.
Eagle County is a member of the Shift Bike program and support stations within unincorporated Eagle County, specifically the expansion into Edwards in 2023. In this role, Eagle County has the direct agreement with the vendor for Edwards hub locations. Eagle County is also involved in planning and operations discussions, and has assisted in grant writing for the program.
Walking Mountains Science Center is a nonprofit that facilitates the Eagle County Climate Action Collaborative, bringing together different public and private stakeholders to discuss climate and sustainability issues. There are six different working groups within the Climate Action Collaborative, one of them focused on transportation; these working groups meet biannually.
Drop Mobility is the turnkey operator for the Shift Bike program in all of the partner communities. Drop Mobility provides the e-bikes for the program along with the software platform, which includes the customer-facing smartphone app to unlock the e-bikes and a platform for partner communities’ staff members to view bike locations and download reports. Drop Mobility is responsible for bicycle maintenance and rebalancing along with technical support for the software platform.
Shift Bike program goals are summarized in Table 3. Between the various partner members, goals for the Shift Bike program included providing first- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops, reducing emissions from automobiles, providing a community amenity through increased mobility access, increasing service for all groups, and supplementing the transit system. According to the IGA between partners, the expansion of stations in the Shift Bike system were implemented in locations with high-density workforce housing and significant first- and last-mile challenges for travel.
Table 3. Shift Bike Program Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Program Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops | ✔ |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.) | |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.) |
A major focus of partners in Eagle County is identifying ways to reduce GGE in the region, both to improve air quality and to protect the natural climate of the regional (e.g., fostering snowfall). According to the county’s Climate Action Plan (updated 2020), the region has goals of reducing GGE 25 percent by 2025, 50 percent by 2030 and 80 percent by 2050 (Longwell, 2022). Additionally, the Town of Vail’s Environmental Sustainability Strategic Plan transportation goal is to reduce the environmental impact of transportation by decreasing total vehicle miles traveled in their area by 20 percent below 2006 levels. The name of the bikeshare program is even a nod toward trying to shift behaviors in local transportation away from taking trips exclusively using single-occupancy vehicles.
The Climate Action Collaborative: Climate Action Plan—Update 2020 includes two stated initiatives related to the bikeshare, the latter of which the Shift Bike program directly addresses (Climate Action Collaborative, 2020):
Each partner community looked at where their own community needs for stations were located; for multiple partners, workforce housing areas were a primary focus area for locating Shift Bike stations. Placement of many stations is intended to help local residents take trips and get to key destinations of interest without needing to use a car. Municipalities worked with some owners of housing areas to help determine optimal siting locations, with mixed results in terms of receptiveness and service utilization. Expansion of the Shift Bike program footprint to more outlying areas of the county was also a goal of service provision under the current agreements.
The partners of Shift Bike each planned their own station locations based on observed travel need. Each of the member municipalities functionally has its own sub-network of travel paths (either bike lanes or pathways) that then connect together to the larger regional network for bike travel. Siting of additional stations is often limited to geography in the mountainous region (as well as cost considerations). Stations are sited in places with higher densities and areas of interest (such as grocery stores, transit stops, and major employers); the Town of Vail worked to site some stations nearby deed-restricted affordable housing in the community, providing additional mobility options for those residents. Some of the partner municipalities (like Vail and Avon) have centrally located areas with relatively higher densities, which are key places for bike stations.
The Shift Bike service area in Eagle County has long-distance route corridors (around 30–40 miles), which has a side effect of bikeshare nodes being too far from each other and riders having to deal with large inclines. Most of the Shift Bike trips are shorter, but some longer trips will be taken between long distance stations in the member communities. For example, Vail is around 10 miles to Avon or 15 miles to Edwards by bike, both of which act as sub-networks for the program.
Overall, the geographic challenge of station coverage is still considerable; planners at the member municipalities continue efforts to increase density in their communities in cost-effective ways. There are some neighborhoods that are harder to serve with bikeshare stations due to seasonal factors (e.g., heavy rains and snow) and geographic factors (e.g., steep slopes and low density). Conversely, municipalities have also observed some trails and trailheads that are now overused by the e-bikes, which leads to maintenance needs but shows the popularity of some stations sited near trails.
Shift Bike is also currently still a seasonal program offering due to the winter weather months when biking is less palatable for riders and harder from an operations perspective (e.g., rebalancing and battery swapping). Presently, Shift Bike months of operations are typically from June–October, though the partner group is hoping to push the beginning of the upcoming operational season to May.
In Vail, there are three bikeshare stops that are specifically designed and placed to provide additional access during seasons with better weather. Partners will turn off some stations from the system during seasons with more inclement weather. The vendor has a warehouse into which they put the e-bikes during the winter since the tires will not handle the winter environment; partners noted that it is important operationally for the storage warehouse to be located within the service area (rather than in a nearby community/county).
Shift Bike originally started in 2020 with $25,000 in initial funding for a one-year pilot with 12 bikes in Vail (Ling, 2023). The Shift Bike program today is significantly larger; partner communities recognize that the turnkey service is not cheap to operate, but they see significant value gained by the use of the system and fewer automobile trips taken.
For a given year, each partner tells the vendor what their budget is for service in their community; then the vendor determines how many stations and e-bikes the partner can receive in return for that budgeted amount. The vendor develops a proposal showing each community’s share of hubs and e-bikes along with the costs for each; once all parties are in agreement, the specifications are written into the separate contract agreements between the vendor and each community. In 2023, per the IGA, the total budget for Shift Bike was $428,150; contributions from each partner were: Vail $223,743 (52.2 percent), Avon $96,679 (22.6 percent), EagleVail $38,672 (9 percent), Eagle County Government $50,000 (11.7 percent), and Edwards Metro District $19,056 (4.5 percent).
In 2023, the partner communities (with the Town of Vail as the lead applicant) received $50,000 through the Colorado DOT’s Transportation Demand Management Innovation Grant. This funding did not pay for all of the costs for Shift Bike, but it did help proportionately offset the expansion costs to the system in each partner community. Per the IGA, the Town of Vail is responsible for grant reporting requirements and distribution of the funds to the other partner communities. Other funding comes from local financial contributions from the municipalities, typically from their general funds; local support within each community and the county has been strong up this point.
Currently, the Shift Bike municipalities do not have business sponsors or formal arrangements with employers in the area. The partners are looking to increase sponsorships this upcoming year, which would help increase station density without partner funding being required. There are some donations that have occurred (such as Vail Health donating helmets), but not any donations substantial enough to support a bikeshare station (estimated at about $15k per year). Ideally, Shift Bike would have a true adopt-a-station model in place. The partners are also working with the vendor to seek out these sponsors, developing a packet of information together to support that effort.
For the recent Shift Bike system expansion, each partner looked at their own service area and determined where additional stations would be useful to residents. The Town of Vail received a lot of feedback in 2022 after the launch, taking these comments into consideration during expansion in tandem with looking at it as an amenity to workforce housing. For the community of Edwards, expansion of service to the western side of their community, with significant workforce housing developments as well as a mobile home park, was a priority of the expansion in order to provide better mobility options for the harder-to-serve area. Multiple partners expect workforce housing to be an ongoing focus with future program expansions, since new workforce housing tends to have limited parking because it can be a significant driver of construction costs, along with residents needing alternative mobility options.
Shift Bike is intended to help encourage local residents to utilize a non-automobile option through the electric-assist bicycles to make pedaling easier. The mountainous topography of Eagle County
and long commutes are often deterrents for residents to utilize traditional human-powered methods, such as traditional biking, when commuting to and from work, as acknowledged in Avon and EagleVail’s RFP for regional electric bikeshare service.
Resort communities in the county (such as the town of Vail) are experiencing urban levels of congestion and transit use, but not at the scale of a larger city. There are also seasonal issues from differences in congestion during ski season and certain holidays compared to the rest of the year. Factors for placing stations for Shift Bike included addressing overuse of some trails and trailheads by bicycles, high automobile parking in some neighborhoods, and observed uses of bicycles parked at bus stops.
The intent of Shift Bike is for the service to be focused on local residents, helping them commute to work or take other needed trips. The program is not intended to serve more recreational bikeshare users, particularly tourists, since the town does not want to compete with private e-bicycle rental companies in the area. Shift Bike uses both pay-as-you-go and membership models for members, who must be local residents (validated by zip code). Trip purpose of Shift Bike rides is not captured, but partners observe there is a mixture of commute/errand trips with recreational trips; some rides also feed into transit stops, aided by the placement of Shift Bike stations nearby.
The Shift Bike website includes information on the differences between recreational bikeshare companies and the Shift Bike program, messaging the latter as intended for short trips (under an hour) such as commuting, errands, or social events while also enabling travel both within and between towns. The website includes a list of bike shops in the county with rental programs to help those looking to rent e-bikes for longer, recreational rides (RealVail, 2023).
Operationally Shift Bike is serving places of need well; partners observe that some stations have really high demand while others have not hit expected utilization levels yet. Rebalancing of bikes during the day by the vendor can sometimes be an issue to help move bikes back to higher demand stations. Partners noted that it is important to have an operations manager (hired by the vendor) that already lives locally in the area in order to be accustomed to the community. Wayfinding can also be an issue for some novice users, so having wayfinding stations and marked dismount zones is another need to make sure riders are safe in higher trafficked areas in town.
The partners do not have issues with service supply from a standpoint of finding vehicles since this is handled by the vendor. Some requests for service cannot be met due to system viability and available funding. Stations for Shift Bike are currently partially distributed among member towns, according to proportional investment. For areas with higher bikeshare use, there is an observed need to expand some bike paths or reduce the number of redundant bike paths going between the same places.
During their initial pilot, Vail had initial pushback from other bike rental tourism companies about its e-bikeshare program but priced the service at a rate to avoid competition with them. For monthly and seasonal memberships, the rider must live, work, or own property in Eagle County. In setting up Shift Bike, partners wanted to make sure that tourists wanting to bike for the day were not using Shift Bike and that it would be more cost-effective to use rentals from a local bike shop. There is
still a push-pull in the pricing model, aiming to keep prices low enough that people will try the system but high enough that tourists are driven toward other rental services.
The current pricing model is structured as pay-as-you-go or memberships (with different available tiers). Monthly and seasonal memberships are available only to local residents. An Equity Membership is available to those who qualify by demonstrating financial need. Partners estimated the breakdown of users to be around 65 percent pay-as-you-go and 35 percent memberships. Based on the reports received by the partners from the vendor, most of the rider zip codes are local to Eagle County; partners recognize that this is an imperfect method of measuring system use by local residents. Pricing tiers are as follows (Deck, 2023):
Broadly, the partners find that the turnkey arrangement is beneficial for smooth operations of the bikeshare program rather than learning how to handle operational components themselves. Some vendors may have unfamiliarity with specific regional contexts for operations (geographic constraints, cost of living, etc.) before coming in to provide service. For instance, hiring operations staff in the region was an initial challenge for the vendor due to hiring issues; conversely, bringing in staff not from the region (particularly in rural tourist communities) can ultimately lead to greater turnover.
An additional operations issue with the turnkey model is having trouble finding available warehouse space for vehicle storage during periods when the service is unavailable. In Eagle County, under-anticipated cost for warehouse space was also an issue at the beginning of the pilot, and a temporary solution to find a warehouse further away (in another county) was ultimately counterproductive.
Marketing and customer education efforts for Shift Bike have improved over various stages of the program. At the beginning of the service expansion, Shift Bike did an early bird special for memberships that was ultimately underutilized likely due to marketing not happening soon enough. The vendor has hired a local resident to help with marketing the program, which has been a great addition particularly in increasing social media presence. However, this position is not full-time and the impacts are still limited as a consequence.
The vendor provides the partner members with data and reports on system performance on a regular basis. All partners’ staff receive weekly reports on system usage, while the Town of Vail additionally requests daily reports and data; the vendor provides raw data (in a .csv format) on trip usage, registrations, and membership types. The level of reports and data provided by the vendor are based on partner preferences (rather than limitations and constraints imposed). The Town of Vail prefers to monitor the program more closely, while other partners do not have the additional staff time to look at program performance more granularly.
The reports include information on three regularly assessed performance measures: average distance, average ride time, and station usage; all of the partners look at these metrics as a part of their
monitoring of program performance. The raw data provided by the vendor are much more detailed and include information on ride origins and destinations, trip distances, and other similar attributes. The raw data do not include information on zip codes of riders, making it somewhat hard to gauge the percentage of riders who are local versus out of town. Currently, there is not an online dashboard with live/refreshed data on Shift Bike, which could provide further utility in looking at performance and downloading data/reports/graphical outputs as needed.
As noted earlier, a major goal of the Shift Bike program is helping reduce GGE in the region. The vendor utilizes a coefficient to determine GGE savings from the service, though more detailed information about those impacts and accounting for bicycle redistribution would be useful. Eagle County contracts with a nonprofit to conduct a transportation emissions inventory, but results are only available at a high level.
Overall, these numbers on GGE are hard to quantify because of not knowing whether the bike trip replaced a car trip, accounting for rebalancing, and accounting for other operations support for Shift Bike. Additional insights on these outcomes would be helpful in providing evidence of program impact to town councils and county leadership in future conversations about further funding support. In addition to GGE data, local government leaders are also interested in measures related to cost per ride and level of demand at stations.
Overall, the program has not observed widespread challenges with broadband and cellular infrastructure coverage either from a user perspective or program operations and administration. There are a few areas in the region where cellular coverage is not strong, but given where stations are currently located, these areas have not been a challenge. Cellular infrastructure was recently upgraded in the region by telecommunications companies to coincide with the World Skiing Championships. There are instances when the rider is unable to end their trip properly with the smartphone app and lock the e-bike at the hub; in these cases, vendor staff will remotely make a manual correction and check on the vehicle if needed.
The swappable batteries on the e-bikes are all working as expected and have had benefits with respect to infrastructure implications. In the 2020 pilot in Vail, batteries were fixed to the e-bikes and were recharged when the vehicle was docked at a station (meaning the station needed to be electrified). With swappable batteries under the current vendor, not only can e-bikes be functionally recharged sooner (by operations staff) but stations/hubs for e-bikes do not need to be electrified.
One issue for the municipal partners with the current model is the emissions occurring from the fleet used by vendor operations staff to rebalance e-bikes and swap out batteries. The partners are working with the vendor to obtain a cargo e-bike or electric van for these purposes, including potential funding subsidies to help in operations e-vehicle procurement.
As mentioned earlier, Shift Bike has the membership level available to riders that demonstrate need for financial assistance. Demonstration of financial need can be done through multiple ways (e.g., through the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, the Low-Income Energy Assistance Program, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, Medicaid, unemployment verification
letters, and tax returns). Proof of need is submitted through the Shift Bike app. The partners’ focus on locating stations near deed-restricted, affordable, and workforce housing is also driven by goals to provide service equitably. Increased utilization of these stations and memberships through better marketing efforts is a soft goal of the partners.
Presently, there are not any accessible/adaptive e-bikes in the fleet provided for Shift Bike. Partners have been in conversation with the vendor to add these vehicles into the fleet; an additional step is figuring out where key station locations should be. Partners would also like to add a few e-cargo bikes to the fleet for users running errands.
The vendor for Shift Bike provides all informational materials in Spanish. Memberships (at $25) provide access to the entire system. Shift Bikes do not come with helmets; the town has worked with a local public health organization to organize helmet giveaways at events and give them out at businesses nearby stations.
The smartphone app for Shift Bike is specific to the program, and there is only one app for the whole region (meaning users to not need to download separate apps to use e-bikes in each community). The Town of Vail is currently exploring an idea for a mobility pass, with the aim to integrate fare payment for transit, bikeshare, and other mobility options under a single app. Ideally this app would be able to integrate with the Shift Bike app, but at the moment it is uncertain how this would work.
Eagle Valley Transportation Authority (EVTA) (currently in the development stage) could be the key entity for a one-stop shop for all things mobility-related. Another goal is to get more communities in the region under EVTA into the Shift Bike program for further expansion.
The partners have not experienced any significant issues with liability for the Shift Bike program. Under their agreements with partner communities, the vendor is required to maintain workers’ compensation insurance and commercial general liability insurance (minimum combined single limits of $1M and $1/$2M general aggregate). For the agreement with the Town of Vail, the vendor is additionally required to carry professional liability insurance (minimum limits of $1M for each claim and $2M general aggregate). The partners are also indemnified from all claims and liability for injuries and other similar instances with the program under this agreement.
There are some local concerns about fire risk with batteries on e-bikes. None of the Shift Bikes from the vendor have had an incident to date. There was recently a fire with a privately owned e-bike in Vail, which has raised awareness of the issue. For Shift Bike, the vendor has provided information and assurances to the partners on their battery-testing process; currently there is no UL Standards certification for them (which the partners would prefer). The partners are also working with the local fire departments to provide information on locations of e-bike storage, create processes for transporting batteries by operations staff, and display required placards.
Helmets are recommended for riding Shift Bikes, but no enforcement is in effect. The program has also worked with community stakeholder organizations (e.g., Vail Health) to periodically give out helmets at events and nearby locations; there is not a formal agreement in place for the helmet distribution initiative. Vail has an injury prevention specialist position that is taking on the helmet donations project.
The Shift Bike program is a model example in regional collaboration in developing a bikeshare program with neighboring community partners in a rural setting. This joint program helps improve the quality and access of service to residents traveling in the community and from communities nearby. Working together with other local partners also increases the buying power of the group for soliciting turnkey vendors and enables the collaborative to seek additional grant program funding opportunities to supplement local contributions.
Shift Bike partners also embedded a focus on accessible service provision in multiple aspects of the program, first in targeting station locations near housing developments and key destinations for low-income residents. Additionally, there is a membership level for the program at a significantly lower cost for users in need, along with a variety of methods for applicants to demonstrate need of this membership. Shift Bike also provides an example for rural communities with tourist activity on balancing priorities toward serving local residents with mobility options.
Because of the type of turnkey vendor and vehicles available, this bikeshare model is also easier to implement than other docked station services since physical charging hubs are not required for the vehicles. Stations/hubs can subsequently be changed in the technology platform with ease, should the community wish to do so. The flexibility of this bikeshare model could have appeal in other rural communities with similar challenges. Conversely, the higher cost for using a turnkey vendor in all operational aspects may be not feasible for many communities.
Shift Bike has ongoing geographic limitations on where stations can be placed, both from operations and rider comfort perspectives. Additionally, the winter weather season (of great importance to the local economy) also makes operations unrealistic for several months of the year. These seasonal and geographic limitations are likely present in other northern/mountainous rural communities as well.
Table 4 summarizes the key successes of the Shift Bike program and the key barriers that the program has faced.
Table 4. Shift Bike Successes and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|
The Wood County Health Department in Wood County, WI, manages the bikeshare program in the county, branded as two separate systems: River Riders Bike Share and Marshfield Community Bikeshare. The systems are located in separate cities 37 miles apart within Wood County (Wisconsin Rapids and Marshfield); though the program is branded differently in the two locations, functionality
it is the same system through the same technology vendor. Wood County’s current bikeshare program is a successful evolution from a grassroots effort to provide a community bikeshare option. Since 2021, Wood County has implemented a model using publicly owned bicycles by the county connected to a technology platform for travelers to check out the vehicles. Wood County’s program also is an example of a lead agency collaborating with multiple local partners to determine community mobility needs and foster support in smaller rural towns.
Wood County previously started a small grassroots bikeshare program called River Riders in Wisconsin Rapids in 2015. The County then worked with a vendor for a turnkey model from 2018 to 2020, which ceased operations in 2020 (during the COVID-19 pandemic). The County shifted its approach to purchase new bikes and work with a technology-only provider. Subsequently, the River Riders Bike Share program was relaunched in 2021 with the county-owned bikes using Koloni as the technology vendor.
Currently, the River Riders Bike Share service has six stations in the City of Wisconsin Rapids with 30 bicycles. Also in 2021, the County expanded the system into Marshfield with an additional four stations and 20 bikes. Bikes can be checked out for a rate of $1.00/hour (Healthy People Wood County, 2024).
There are three pieces of technology associated with the bikeshare program: the smart lock hardware added to the bike, the smartphone app, and the management software.
The vehicles for the bikeshare program are standard bicycles with the smart lock technology installed on them. Currently there are 50 total vehicles available between the two services; one of the vehicles is a tandem side-by-side bicycle, and two are adaptive tricycles. Wood County has not had to replace any bikes in the system since 2021.
The Wood County Health Department within Wood County is the managing agency for the bikeshare program, coordinating with the two cities with bikeshare service as well as other community stakeholders on service needs. Wood County has a sole source agreement in place with Koloni to provide the technology; all other coordination and communication with the cities and community foundations is done on an informal basis without agreements in place.
Wood County Health Department is housed within the Wood County government. The department works to promote healthy lifestyles and lead public health initiatives in the county. Wood County does not have a separate bike/pedestrian committee as part of the organization; there is a public works committee, but it is not specific to multimodal transportation. The department also leads the development of the Wood County Community Health Improvement Plan (CHIP), and staff in the department also facilitate and lead the Healthy People Wood County coalition. Additionally, as of 2023 Wood County was working on an update to the county bike/pedestrian plan (North Central Wisconsin Regional Planning Commission, 2023).
The department has been the lead partner for the bikeshare program since its beginnings in 2015, then took over managing the program when it began working with a turnkey vendor in 2018. The department coordinates with other County departments, cities, and community stakeholders on an informal basis. The department conducts an annual meeting near the beginning of bikeshare service
opening for the season to inform stakeholders about service for the upcoming months and any changes that have occurred.
The City of Wisconsin Rapids is an informal partner in the River Riders Bike Share service. The City reviews and provides approval for bikeshare station sites (all of which are on public land in the city) and collaborates with the Wood County Health Department on ideas for improving service. The City periodically provides space to store the bikes indoors as needed during cold weather season when the program is not operational. The City also includes bikeshare as part of its wayfinding signage installed around town to help residents find bikeshare stations.
The City of Marshfield is an informal partner in the Marshfield Community Bikeshare service. The City reviews and provides approval for bikeshare station sites (all of which are on public land in the city) and collaborates with the Wood County Health Department on ideas for improving service. The City periodically provides space to store the bikes indoors as needed during cold weather season when the program is not operational.
Clean Green Action is a local citizen-led, nonprofit organization focused on sustainability and conservation efforts. Members of Clean Green Action originally came up with the idea for the bikeshare program around 2015, which started as a free program with the local community foundation inviting members of the community to donate bicycles for public use. The grassroots effort, which created the original River Riders program, ultimately became the responsibility of Wood County. Clean Green Action no longer has a formal role in the program but has informal advisement with Wood County Health Department about the service.
Koloni is the technology vendor for the current iteration of the bikeshare program, providing the smart locks, smartphone app, and management software that supports service. Koloni works mostly with small- and medium-sized communities to provide bikeshare solutions with its technology. Wood County has a sole source agreement with Koloni to provide the technology pieces for the program; Koloni provides installation/integration assistance with the locks along with troubleshooting assistance with the software as needed, but is otherwise not involved with the service on a day-to-day basis.
Marshfield Area County Foundation, Inc. is a public charity that supports economic development, recreation, environmental protection, and other efforts to enrich quality of life in the city of Marshfield. The foundation does not have a formal role in the Marshfield Community Bikeshare service but provides input informally on service needs to Wood County Health Department. The Marshfield Area Community Foundation provided funding for the program in prior years.
Incourage Community Foundation is a public charity that supports healthy living, environmental protection, and other efforts focusing on opportunity and shared stewardship in the city of Wisconsin Rapids. The foundation does not have a formal role in the River Rides Bike Share service but provides input informally on service needs to Wood County Health Department. The Incourage Community Foundation provided funding for the program in prior years.
Other public and private community partners that provide support to the bikeshare service include (Healthy People Wood County, 2022):1
___________________
1 Agency information
Wood County’s primary goals for the program are to make it accessible to community members and to ensure accessible provision of station sites and vehicles; see Table 5. The County talks to partners to find out about community needs and look for ways to fulfill those needs with the bikeshare program. The County and member cities also look at demographics in the community to connect to transportation need; because of a higher proportion of people with disabilities compared to the state average, having bikeshare vehicles that are accessible to these potential riders is important for the County and member cities. While the bikeshare system is used for many recreation trips, there are some users that check out bikes for commuting to work or trips to the store. The County is interested in reducing barriers to accessing the system for low-income individuals that need the vehicles as a regular transportation option.
Table 5. Wood County Bikeshare Program Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Program Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops | |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.) | |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.) |
Wood County is also interested in expansion of the bikeshare program in other municipalities where service may be viable. The cities of Wisconsin Rapids and Marshfield are far apart, and there has not been an assessment to determine demand, so the program will likely be expanded on a case-by-case basis. It is also important for county leadership that resources for the bikeshare program be distributed equally from a geographic perspective, which can be a challenge given the distribution of population. Wood County is currently in communication with other municipalities to see which ones are interested and where additional resources to expand the program can be obtained so that growth is kept at reasonable and sustainable levels.
CHIP is regularly led and developed by the Wood County Health Department. CHIP for 2020–2024 has multiple transportation objectives related to bikeshare (Wood County Health Department, 2022):
Measures for the above-listed objectives include the number of bikes checked out, miles ridden, trail connections, signage improvements, and recreation data (Wood County Health Department, 2022).
The Wood County Health Department is currently working on updating the Community Health Assessment and will be updating CHIP later this year. The County anticipates that objectives related to the bikeshare program will be similar in the next iteration.
The Wood County Health Department covers staffing costs for administration of the bikeshare program on an in-kind basis. The program has covered costs for technology and maintenance through a combination of smaller business grants, private donations, and sponsorships. The County supports the program for local match on vehicles purchased through grant funding, and in-kind staffing contributions from the county health department have helped as well. The vehicles and station infrastructure were supported by local grants from a local private foundation and the Wisconsin Partnership Program.
A challenge is sustained financial support from the local municipalities. The County recognizes that relying on grant funding is not sustainable for the program in the long term and is looking at getting more permanent funding from municipalities. The Town of Grand Rapids is one partner that annually commits $2,500 to the program, supporting one station located in its municipality. The core group of stakeholders that collaborated for the initial bikeshare pilot still help foster support and demonstrate need for the service locally. The County noted that more information on trip purpose of rides would be helpful in efforts to procure more funding. Clean Green Action does a paper survey once a year, which gathers details on community needs, some of which include bikeshare information.
The County will seek out businesses that are willing to sponsor a station; sponsorship provides businesses the benefit of being listed at that station as well as within materials and social media posts about the program. The sponsorships have been particularly effective in the Marshfield service area, and for the most part sponsors do not turn over. Getting more sponsors for stations is a goal; currently there are three sponsored stations in Wisconsin Rapids and two in Marshfield.
Sponsorship support levels are available to help cover the partial (half) or full cost of a single station for one year, including five bikes, the docking platform, and other administrative and operations components (estimated at $3,000 total). A full sponsorship yields a logo on both sides of the bike basket, choice of station site to sponsor, logos and promotion on bikeshare marketing materials and postings, and choice of station site to sponsor (a partial sponsorship only includes marketing materials and posting) (Healthy People Wood County, 2024).
The County purchased new bikes for the relaunch of the program in 2021, and thus far no replacements have been required. One of the adaptive bikes did get damaged and removed from the fleet, due to the cost of fixing it being too high. Adaptive bikes are harder to find and more expensive to purchase. The system also does not have any electric bikes that would assist users in pedaling, due to the additional expenses and maintenance challenges associated with them. Program stakeholders note that e-bikes would be a great option for encouraging program use and attracting more riders.
Weather also plays a factor in service viability. During the winter, the County hibernates the bikes due to weather and less community desire to bike in the cold.
All of the bikeshare stations are located on public property, either near trails or by key community destinations. The cities have also added bike lanes in some places to help improve safety for bikeshare users (as well as other riders). Stations have been sited with the help of community stakeholder input and in conjunction with safe pathways for riding.
Collaborating with community organizations to check out bikes for individuals that do not have a smartphone or are unbanked could be considered in order to improve access. However, barriers exist to this solution such as training staff to learn how to check out a bike for others and a way to ensure bikes are returned.
Based on observations from Wood County Health Department and other program partners, the bikeshare program primarily serves as a recreation option for some users; other users use the program as a means for regular local trips in the community. During the previous iteration of the program with a turnkey provider, Wood County was able to look at data on trip use by residents. Many trips were (and continue to be) taken by local low-income populations taking commute trips to work.
Some of the bikeshare stations have been located in historically under-resourced neighborhoods and at key community activity locations, such as local libraries and grocery stores. Ultimately, one goal is to find funds to subsidize the cost of rides for users with low incomes.. The County and partners see that there is a significant need for the bikeshare service from growing populations of those without motor vehicles, unhoused individuals, and refugees. Additional customer education and awareness campaigns about the program is needed to build additional rider demand.
The county board has been very supportive of the bikeshare program thus far. In Wood County there is a need to make sure that resources are balanced between the northern and southern areas of the county (where Marshfield and Wisconsin Rapids are respectively situated). A lot of the other places in the county where bikeshare is not currently available are even smaller communities. Wood County has received a lot of inquiries on possible expansion of the bikeshare program from other communities both within and outside the county. Due to the large amount of capacity needed to manage a bikeshare program, as well as capital costs for the stations and fleet for expansion, it is uncertain whether the expense to additional areas would provide enough benefit to justify the service.
The County found the shift to the county-owned vehicle model (in which the County purchases the bicycle fleet themselves rather than relying on a turnkey provider) has been much more viable. So far, in the current iteration of the program, there has not been a need to purchase additional bikes to meet trip demand. The County has not had to replace any bicycles in the fleet yet. The longevity of the bikes is about five years of regular use before major upgrades are needed, so additional costs for bike maintenance/purchases are anticipated on that timeline. When a new bike does get purchased for the system, the technology vendor installs the smart lock on the vehicle or works with an existing lock using Bluetooth to integrate it with the software platform; theoretically any bike could be added to the system in this manner.
The cost to purchase bikes was found to be most difficult at the time of the program relaunch; a braided funding model of smaller grants and donations was used to pay for the expenses. The current software vendor is relatively inexpensive (at around $10,000 annually) since bike operations and maintenance are not included in the cost. The County pays a maintenance technician around $6,000 annually to visit each service zone once per week; this technician takes care of rebalancing and maintenance needs of the vehicles themselves.
The County tracks metrics on trips taken and miles ridden by users from the software platform, which also provides information on origin and destination points of the trips (where bikes are unlocked and locked, respectively). These data help measure progress on the related CHIP objectives. Data results from the River Riders Bike Share and Marshfield Community Bikeshare annual reports are shown in Table 6 (Healthy People Wood County, 2022):
Table 6. Wood County Bikeshare Ridership by Service, 2021–2022
| Service | Rides | |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 2022 | |
| River Riders | 321 | 576 |
| Marshfield | 203 | 275 |
At present, the software does not provide additional data points on travel paths of bikes during the trip; the County has previous experience with using these “breadcrumb data” for taking detailed looks at trip paths when it was working with a turnkey vendor. Detailed travel path data are useful for plotting additional bike lanes and identifying places for bikeshare stations/storage. Trip purpose of specific user trips is also not available from the software at this time. Currently, the County uses the origin and destination data along with observations gathered from community stakeholders to help inform further planning on the system.
The County currently does not have metrics connected to goals to reduce chronic disease, which is one of the goals of the bikeshare program. The local health department will do data analyses on chronic disease every so often, and the County will work with the health department on how it can change the built environment to help address these needs (such has better connectivity, additional bike lanes, and improved signage). The stakeholder groups note that additional data measuring how bikeshare is good for economic development would be beneficial in securing regular funding for the program.
The program does not have any significant issues with broadband or cellular infrastructure in either of the two service areas. Cellular coverage is consistently available for smartphones to be able to unlock and lock the vehicles. The geofences for both service areas are also fairly large and have not presented any operational issues.
The smart locks themselves use local Bluetooth technology reliant on battery power; these batteries are swapped out by the maintenance technician when they begin running low. There have been some instances of the signals from a few smart locks not consistently working; in these cases, the smart lock is repaired or replaced. The County notes that the program’s self-management model allows for some flexibility (in comparison to a turnkey vendor) on what bikes to purchase or retrofit as well as when the purchases are made.
The County had conversations with community members on where they wanted locations of the stations and bike lanes along with safety concerns to makes sure the system would be used.
The County has goals to make the program accessible for residents by keeping the price down for rides; this has been made possible through local grant funding from a private foundation and nonprofits. The program currently uses a pay-as-you-go model for fees (at $1 per hour), which has proven to be more popular with riders than the previous iteration, which had membership rates. However, this has made access for persons who are unbanked a challenge; a workaround solution from the technology vendor is for these riders to work with community organizations to check out bikes. This workaround structure has a high learning curve for riders and employees alike, since training is needed on how to check out bicycles in this manner.
The pay-as-you-go model has proven to be more popular for the program than previous versions with membership rates, so there is not likely to be a change from it. The County has considered how to work in promotion codes or credits based on volunteer hours to help encourage utilization. Right now, there are no other payment levels available for low-income users, which is being explored as well. Ideally, the program could help cover the cost of rides by low-income users long term.
The County is also looking to increase customer education campaign efforts through bike events in order to encourage further usage of the systems. The program has held events in the past offering free rides and promotional giveaways for attendees; some community events have been in conjunction with the local police departments (Healthy People Wood County, 2022).
As noted earlier, the County does have a few accessible bikes in the system; two are tricycles, and one is a tandem side-by-side bike. (The latter is popular and has had issues with vandalism.) Figure 11 shows an example of these vehicles.
The County has not experienced any significant issues with liability and risk in the program thus far. In the smartphone app there is a user agreement that includes acceptance of liability for injuries and incidents when riding the bike; riders must agree to this before being able to check out a bike for the first time. There are also no additional insurance needs for the County to administer the program or for the cities to have the bikeshare stations.
Wood County’s bikeshare program is an example of a relative low-cost solution to micromobility that is scalable to include more service capacity (i.e., stations and bikes) based on further increases in service demand. The program has a flat cost for licensing the software platform from the technology vendor, and the County controls other costs for bikes and stations itself (along with ongoing maintenance for both). The program is an example of patient growth and a low-cost mobility option that can be implemented in rural communities with enough population density for local travel. Other rural counties and small towns could consider this type of bikeshare option if there are a few key areas where local bike trips would be taken by potential users.
Wood County’s program has also been successful for its size due to the level of community partner involvement and engagement through different iterations of the program. Local support for the bikeshare program is a result of initial grassroots efforts by community organizations to develop the program. These stakeholders have continued to support the bikeshare and assist in the messaging of its mobility value to local governments in the region. Other rural communities looking to add bikeshares can look at community desire for this type of option as a starting point.
The model does have a few areas of improvement for program sustainability to be considered. Since the relaunch of the program was chiefly dependent on one-time grant funding, further development of regular funding streams is needed in the future when bikes need to be replaced or additional stations are desired. Data yielded directly from the program have limitations in their granularity, since further information would be useful for planning purposes and messaging travel needs in appeal for sustainable funding. The model also has barriers present for those without a smartphone or needing other payment or fee options for checking out bikes.
Table 7 summarizes the key successes of the Wood County Bikeshare program and the key barriers that the program has faced.
Table 7. Wood County Bikeshare Program Successes and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|
HealthTran currently helps people in 42 Missouri counties make healthcare-related trips using all of the available area transportation services. The service relies on volunteer drivers who use their personal vehicles to provide rides and are then reimbursed for mileage. Rides can be scheduled within minutes or up to a month in advance. Ideally, trips are scheduled at least three days out. This service is unique because healthcare providers arrange trips, not the person receiving care. Additionally, the service is free to riders. HealthTran’s work as a trip broker between different organizations, focus on medical transportation, and integration of different software platforms into a common platform were identified as features that make HealthTran an interesting example to provide further information for this project.
HealthTran began in 2013 as a pilot project and expanded in 2015 as a collaboration with FMR with a goal of helping people make healthcare-related door-to-door trips using all of the available area transportation services. Currently, the program utilizes the Assisted Rides technology platform. The program has been successful in helping individuals make medical trips they might not otherwise be able to complete. The program now serves as a model for other organizations to emulate. The
United Way of Central Missouri is currently working to expand the current program to additional areas of central Missouri.
The program utilizes the Assisted Rides technology platform. Medical service providers utilize the platform to arrange rides for individuals seeking medical services. Drivers utilize the platform via a smartphone app to accept and manage the rides. HealthTran staff utilize the platform to track results, calculate mileage reimbursement for drivers, bill members, and value volunteer time. The Assisted Rides platform can be integrated into existing systems via an API.
The program relies on volunteer drivers who are recruited from the communities in which HealthTran operates. Volunteer drivers utilize their personal vehicles to make the trip and are reimbursed for their mileage.
HealthTran partners include the Missouri Rural Health Association, Community Asset Builders, Assisted Rides, local medical care providers, and volunteer drivers; each of these are discussed in the following sections.
Missouri Rural Health Association (MRHA) is the FTA grantee. As such, FTA funds flow from FTA to MRHA. MRHA has a management agreement with Community Asset Builders to assure HealthTran meets and exceeds FTA expectations and has the financial resources and stability necessary to be sustainable.
Community Asset Builders is responsible for full implementation and operation of all aspects of HealthTran. This includes staff hiring and management, driver recruitment, training and management, and partner development. Community Asset Builders maintain regular communication with MRHA to assure compliance with FTA expectations and maintain all required assurances for HealthTran to remain an FTA grantee. Community Asset Builders also continues to work on identifying new funding sources.
Assisted Rides is a California based software company that specializes in developing and implementing software focused on mobility solutions. As previously mentioned, Assisted Rides provides the software platform that is the technology framework for HealthTran. There is a formal contract agreement between Community Asset Builders and Assisted Rides, which covers the service agreement and the data sharing agreement.
Local healthcare providers utilize the Assisted Rides platform to arrange rides for patients who might not otherwise be able to make the trips to and from the healthcare facility. Healthcare service providers are also billed for the trip, resulting in a free fare for the individual receiving medical services. Example agreements between Community Asset Builders and local medical providers are included as the Business Associate Agreement and the HealthTran Service Agreement.
Volunteer drivers utilize their own personal vehicle to transport riders to and from the healthcare provider. These drivers utilize the Assisted Rides platform to help manage rides. They are recruited and trained by HealthTran staff.
The program goals for HealthTran are identified in Table 8. Community Asset Builders noted some communities within the service area are served by existing public transportation, while others are not. Furthermore, the on-demand nature of the service is particularly useful for trips that need to be made with little or no advance notification, and/or in instances where existing transportation options (e.g., rides from friends/family) have failed. Community Asset Builders also noted that the demographics it most commonly serves are those without driver’s licenses, older adults, low-income households, and zero-vehicle households.
Table 8. HealthTran Program Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Program Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops. | ✔ |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency. | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.). | |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations. | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.). | ✔ |
HealthTran is currently a direct recipient of Innovative Coordinated Access and Mobility (ICAM) 2 FTA funds; it was also a previous recipient of ICAM and Coordinating Council on Access and Mobility (Mobility for All) funding, also through FTA. The program was previously funded through a grant from the Missouri Foundation for Health and by working with the Missouri DOT to secure Section 5310 funding allocated to Missouri through FTA. HealthTran continues to look for both traditional and non-traditional funding sources since the program is successful and demand is growing. HealthTran pays for the Assisted Rides software platform, driver background checks, employee salaries, and a supplemental insurance policy for volunteer drivers.
Local healthcare providers who want to be part of the program pay a one-time fee that is based on (1) the number of facilities they want served and (2) the location of each of these facilities. This fee covers marketing and community outreach on the transportation program, HealthTran recruiting and training volunteer drivers, onboarding of member destination information into tech platform, assisting with training on the technology/ride scheduling platform, and ongoing technical assistance from HealthTran. A minimum of $8.75 is charged per trip up to five miles, while a per passenger (loaded) per mile fee of $1.75 is charged for legs greater than five miles. A loaded mile is defined as from the time the rider enters the vehicle to when they arrive at the destination. Rider no-show miles are billable. See HealthTran Volunteer Driver Program & Ride Scheduling Platform The Rural Transportation Solution HealthTran Line of Service Cost Sheet for additional details.
Currently there are approximately 20–25 partners participating in the program, with the number of sites per partner ranging from 1 to 15.
Peak demand for HealthTran service usually occurs on Tuesdays or Wednesdays, with the busiest times of day coinciding with typical a.m. and p.m. peak periods. There are three significant challenges facing the service:
Prior to its agreement with Assisted Rides, HealthTran partnered with a few different technology providers who were more focused on partnering with TNCs, as opposed to reliance on volunteer drivers. This model did not work well in the rural service area. Because the current program relies on the personal vehicles of volunteer drivers, vehicle availability is only an issue when volunteers are in short supply.
Community Asset Builders has a data sharing agreement in place with Assisted Rides that provides HealthTran with access to the raw trip data. Additionally, each rider has a profile that contains a wide range of data, such as ethnicity, insurance, household size, etc. HealthTran staff can generate reports and distribute to any partners that ask for this information. Furthermore, Community Asset Builders provides interns to analyze the data and help with FTA reporting metrics.
Healthcare workers have internet access through their facility and are responsible for arranging the ride, which can be requested by the rider at the time the appointment is made or at the time of the
appointment. The riders themselves never access the platform. Drivers occasionally have cellular network issues in remote rural areas, but these issues are not overly common. Drivers that have connectivity issues can call HealthTran to obtain information about rides.
One key component of the service that addresses accessibility is that the service is free to riders, with the fare paid for by the medical care provider. All billing is conducted by Community Asset Builders. As previously mentioned, working with Medicaid can be a challenge, but HealthTran does not have income or insurance-related participation requirements. Participating healthcare provider organizations are encouraged to review their own data to identify patients at high risk for missing appointments and/or having a chronic health condition that is not being managed well. These patients represent a significant opportunity to improve health outcomes for the patient and to decrease use of emergency departments for healthcare conditions better managed at the primary care level. Investing in transportation eliminates barriers to accessing healthcare and improves the health status of patients.
Prior to launching the program, HealthTran had to invest in its cyber security infrastructure, since it wanted to assure its partners—particularly hospitals, since they have been the repeated target of cyber attacks—as well as the FTA and the communities they serve that data security is a priority. HealthTran has not filed any insurance claims, though it does carry a significant amount of liability insurance. It also carries a policy for drivers that covers the rider in the event of an accident. Drivers are drug tested and background checked.
Programs such as Missouri’s HealthTran are vital in filling existing mobility gaps, particularly those that exist for individuals who, without such programs, might not be able to make trips to healthcare providers. Challenges such as volunteer driver recruitment and clearly explaining to healthcare service providers the value of the service do exist. However, through the use of a myriad of driver recruitment strategies and the development of cost benefit models, these challenges can be effectively managed. Organizations looking to implement similar models would be well-served to assess the potential of billing the medical care service provider for the trip, instead of the rider. While this may require more up-front engagement with the medical care service provider, this model results in a lower barrier-to-entry for riders who might otherwise face payment obstacles, such as affordability of trip or, for the underbanked, inability to pay electronically for the trip.
VDPs like HealthTran may be of utility to rural organizations looking to address the mobility needs of their community. Not only do volunteer programs effectively manage the issue of vehicle shortages, but volunteer drivers can also form strong social ties to those they serve, which can lead to enduring relationships that extend beyond the traditional rider-driver paradigm.
Table 9 summarizes the key successes of the HealthTran program and the key barriers that the program has faced.
Table 9. HealthTran Program Success and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|
The Catch-A-Ride programs in Wisconsin’s Winnebago and Waupaca Counties provide affordable transportation options for the workers with low incomes in those areas as well as the general public in Waupaca County. Each program functions as a MaaS concept with county-specific service characteristics such as income eligibility guidelines, volunteer drivers, and reduced fare structures. These concepts offer examples of successful partnership with a unique, rural-focused TNC.
The Catch-A-Ride program was initially established in Winnebago County, WI, as a gap-filling service with the goal of helping people with low incomes get to and from work via rides provided by volunteer drivers. After this program was established, the model was adapted in neighboring Waupaca County to provide service for all riders and all trip purposes throughout that county via both taxi operators and volunteer drivers. Both programs are managed by the Make the Ride Happen Program of Lutheran Social Services of Wisconsin and Upper Michigan (LSS) and use the FMR MaaS platform.
In Winnebago County, the Catch-A-Ride program was originally funded through a Commute to Careers grant sponsored by the Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development and the Wisconsin DOT, with additional funding obtained from nonprofit stakeholders in the county. Service was planned via an informal agreement between service stakeholders and Make the Ride Happen (MTRH) and started with a volunteer recruitment effort. After conducting volunteer recruitment, it was determined that additional transportation providers would be necessary, so the planning group asked local taxi companies if they would be interested in working with the program. After the first company was on board and established, the same process was used to recruit other companies.
To be eligible for service in Winnebago County riders must not have access to public transportation either during work hours, or at the home or work addresses. These riders are required to apply by submitting wage verification information and undergoing a phone interview with an MTRH representative. Eligible riders pay $0.50 per mile for each trip for the first 90 days of service eligibility. After 90 days, the fare increases to $1.75 per ride plus $0.75 per mile, which increases to $6.75 per ride and $3.00 per mile after one year of program eligibility. Rides are provided by via taxis and volunteer drivers, and volunteer drivers are reimbursed at a rate of $0.58 per mile for driving their own vehicle. While Winnebago Catch-A-Ride was being planned, FMR was working in Winnebago County and received an Easter Seals grant to fund its planning and piloting of the MaaS system as well as the time required to seek buy-in from stakeholders. Easter Seals introduced MTRH to FMR and, subsequently, FMR was brought on board to support the Winnebago operations via a
memorandum of understanding between the company and MTRH/LSS. FMR provides software for trip assignment and routing as well as call center support.
Until December 2023, there was no transit service in Waupaca County. Catch-A-Ride was implemented as a countywide service without eligibility requirements (but with a focus on providing transportation options for workers with low incomes). In Waupaca County, Catch-A-Ride is funded via a three year, $3.2 million grant from the State of Wisconsin’s Workforce Innovation group. The Waupaca County Development Corporation is the lead recipient for the Innovation grant, and both LSS and FMR are subrecipients. The program also receives funding from some of the local municipalities and United Way. The program also seeks funding from local employers that are incentivized to support the service because of its ability to help them attract or retain staff, but this funding source has not yet begun. FMR provides the service platform (rider and driver apps as well as a backoff interface), vehicles, drivers, and call center staff. Both taxi services and volunteer drivers supplement the capacity that FMR provides via its drivers/vehicles. Riders pay $3.00 per ride as of this writing; however, the program anticipates introducing a more nuanced fare structure in the future to account for longer and out-of-county trips and incorporated reduced fares.
FMR provides all of the technology used for both the Winnebago and Waupaca Catch-A-Ride programs including rider and driver apps, dispatching and management software, and credit/debit card fare payment. FMR software is not integrated with any local transportation service providers.
In Winnebago County, the Catch-A-Ride service is provided via taxi vehicles and volunteer drivers’ personal vehicles. In certain situations, Lyft is used to supplement service, and those drivers supply their own vehicles. In Waupaca County, Catch-A-Ride service is provided via a fleet of small SUVs and an ADA-accessible minivan (as shown in Figure 12) as well as taxi vehicles, volunteer driver vehicles, and Lyft vehicles when needed.
The Catch-A-Ride programs are supported by three key partnerships, as described below.
The MTRH program is a service of LSS. MTRH is responsible for managing both the Winnebago and Waupaca Catch-A-Ride programs, and LSS is a subrecipient on the grant that funds service in Waupaca County. MTRH conducts its responsibilities in both Winnebago and Waupaca Counties under separate service agreements.
FMR is the technology partner for the Catch-A-Ride service in both Winnebago and Waupaca Counties. In both counties, FMR provides the software to run the services (rider and driver apps and back-office software for trip assignments/dispatching) as well as call center services for riders with questions or that seek to schedule a ride. In Waupaca County, FMR also provides vehicles and drivers.
The Waupaca County Economic Development Corporation partnered with MRTH/LSS and FMR to pursue the Workforce Innovation grant that currently funds Waupaca Catch-A-Ride and acts as the program’s lead grant recipient.
Catch-A-Ride program goals are summarized in Table 10. Both Catch-A-Ride programs seek to provide transportation to access employment for riders with low incomes as a primary program objective (and an objective that is linked to the funding for each program). The services also help bridge existing gaps in transit service, add capacity to existing services, provide general mobility for historically underserved riders, and improve the quality of the mobility services that are available. In Winnebago County, Catch-A-Ride also facilitates first- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit where that service is available. While Winnebago County riders must qualify for service by having household incomes at or below 150 percent of the federal poverty level, Waupaca County Catch-A-Ride is open to everyone. For Winnebago service, trips are not allowed if the origin and destination are within ¾ mile of a fixed-route transit option so that Catch-A-Ride does not compete with the existing transit system.
Both Catch-A-Ride programs have experienced high demand for service—Winnebago is currently closed for service applications, and Waupaca provided over 6,000 trips in its first year. Despite filling a need in the communities they serve, the programs have had some challenges.
Affordability and sustainability have challenged Catch-A-Ride program in Winnebago County, especially after a funding reduction in 2023. Initially, the service set a rider fare that was too low to make the program sustainable because other funding sources were limited; therefore, fares had to be increased. While the new fare structure is expected to help the program continue to operate, riders have expressed concerns about the cost being higher than is affordable.
Additionally, support for the type of service Catch-A-Ride provides in Winnebago County has not been particularly high during recent planning activities in the county’s largest city, Oshkosh, which may limit the program’s long-term success. Additionally, attracting service providers (e.g., taxi companies or Federal Section 5311 recipients) in Winnebago County has been difficult, which has
limited the total capacity of the service and caused FMR to dispatch trips on Lyft, which increases per-trip costs. (In one instance, a taxi company that was previously working with Catch-A-Ride accepted a contract to provide trips for the transit agency and was then unavailable.)
In Waupaca County, FMR was able to recruit drivers relatively quickly but initially struggled to get vehicles for the service. Additionally, it was difficult to find staff from the community that were interested in working for the existing FMR call center (taking approximately six months). FMR also learned that a local service manager could provide a direct connection to drivers and incorporate local perspective. Other transportation providers in the Waupaca area (e.g., Federal Section 5311 transit systems or existing shared ride service operators that run medical trips) have been hesitant to participate as service providers and work within the FMR system due to concerns related to competition for trips. Volunteer drivers have also been difficult to recruit. As of January 2024, six drivers had volunteered. Last, appropriate vehicle staging remains a challenge for the service and results in long segments of deadhead.
In both service areas, riders are challenged by the requirement that trip changes must be made an hour or more in advance. Shift and hourly workers often experience last-minute changes to their work schedules, which can result in a need to either stay at work longer or not go to work at the planned time. Both situations result in either missed trips or long wait times to get picked up.
Table 10. Catch-A-Ride Program Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Program Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops | ✔* |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.) | ✔ |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.) | ✔ |
*Winnebago County only.
As of this writing, the Catch-A-Ride program in Winnebago County operates at capacity and is not accepting new applications for service eligibility. The riders have provided feedback that the cost to ride is difficult to afford, especially as the initial low-cost period ends, but that they do not have other options.
Waupaca Catch-A-Ride has been running for a year and seen increased ridership every month it has been in operation. As of early January 2024, the service had provided 6,543 trips and served over 270 unique riders, with trips averaging about 32 miles each. Ridership in Waupaca County peaks from 4:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. and from 2:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m. in line with local industry shifts, but as of this writing, a midday peak was beginning to emerge.
Both Catch-A-Ride programs require users to request trips either via the smartphone app or FMR call center, and all fares must be paid via the app. Despite lacking a cash fare payment option, the challenges for riders have been limited to some riders not wanting to share personal information with the system, instead of issues with access to the credit and banking system.
Catch-A-Ride program trips in both Winnebago and Waupaca Counties are first dispatched to a standing pool of volunteer drivers. Any trips that cannot be accommodated via the volunteers are forward to cabs (and in certain situations, Lyft).
To track the Winnebago Catch-A-Ride program’s effectiveness and report to its funders, the staff at MTRH record quarterly data about the following service aspects when the data are available:
The number of jobs accessed or employment tenure are not always supplied by riders.
FMR is responsible for tracking service performance for the Waupaca Catch-A-Ride program in order to report to funders the following:
In both counties, FMR’s system is used for all data collection provided to MTRH and stakeholders via monthly reports and presentations, as required by the FMR contract.
The majority of riders on Waupaca Catch-A-Ride use smartphones and the app; however, some areas have limited connectivity to cellular data. Therefore, in these areas the call center provides a useful backup. Anecdotally, the agency has noticed that older adults have more difficulty with the technology.
When hiring drivers and recruiting volunteers, the agency and FMR strive to find people that are local to the Waupaca County area in an effort to minimize issues associated with not knowing the geography (potentially exacerbated if the FMR app has issues or cellular service is limited).
As noted previously, the fare structure for the Winnebago Catch-A-Ride system has proven to be challenging for people with very low incomes, especially as the rates increase over the time that eligible riders participate in the program. Despite these challenges, the agency cannot reduce the service costs without risking the program’s overall sustainability.
A voucher program is planned to enhance affordability of the Waupaca Catch-A-Ride service. To be eligible for trip vouchers, riders must show proof of household income that is at or below 250 percent of the federal poverty level. The income level for eligibility in Winnebago County is mandated by the funding source used for that program at 150 percent of the federal poverty level, or less; in running this program, MTRH and FMR determined that a higher threshold for reduced fares was best, hence the 250 percent threshold for reduced fares in Waupaca County. These riders will receive trip vouchers that reduce the cost of each trip from $3 to $2 for a period of 90 days.
Waupaca County has a large Hispanic population. In an effort to ensure these members of the community knew about the Catch-A-Ride program and could access it if desired, MTRH staff worked with Hispanic leaders to conduct outreach. Connections were made via chamber of commerce members, a local church, and the staff’s personal contacts. Despite the outreach it appears that this community is still hesitant to participate in the program. Anecdotally, MTRH thinks that the requirement to share some personal information (e.g., name, destination address, digital payment details, employment information if applying for vouchers) may be intimidating for the Hispanic community.
Regarding language access, the FMR app initially had difficulty with Spanish language translation, but that was fixed in the early stages of service deployment. The call center also has access to translation services if needed. Language needs in the area for people that do not speak English regularly include Spanish and Hmong, but other languages are expected to become more prevalent as people emigrate from other countries (e.g., Myanmar, Afghanistan, and Iran).
Neither the Winnebago nor the Waupaca Catch-A-Ride programs have had issues related to ADA accessibility. Liability is handled by separate insurance policies held by each of the participating entities.
The Catch-A-Ride programs offer interesting insights about the design and provision of MaaS concepts in rural and small urban areas as well as a model for how to plan and manage such a program via collaborative efforts. The service in Winnebago County was implemented first and provided a useful set of lessons regarding necessary funding levels as well as affordability accommodations and service operations (e.g., dedicated drivers and vehicles) that were leveraged to improve on the concept when it was launched in Waupaca County. Both programs were developed collaboratively using input from stakeholders such as social service organizations, funders, and technology/transportation providers—a model that leverages each participant’s expertise while sharing startup costs and risks between the group.
Notably, day-to-day management of the Catch-A-Ride programs is handled by a social service-oriented nonprofit, which helps the programs—intended to first serve riders with low incomes and help them access employment—maintain focus on the service goals. A similar model in other communities with specific needs (e.g., access to education) could be used by integrating relevant organizations in leadership positions. Additionally, the technology partner is a nonprofit corporation with a specific focus on transportation service provision in rural areas of the United States, which brings unique perspective and expertise to the service.
The service is challenged by some local conditions. In Winnebago County, funding for the program was recently reduced due to limited political support, and in both counties, other transportation providers have struggled to see the Catch-A-Ride program as an opportunity (e.g., to work as service
providers and supplement their existing business) instead of competition. Other challenges that the programs still need to address include limited access for people that choose or need to pay cash, hesitation among the Hispanic riders about the information they must submit in order to participate, and recruitment and retention of volunteer drivers (a key component of long-term financial sustainability in areas with limited available funding).
Table 11 summarizes the key successes of the Catch-A-Ride program and the key barriers that the program has faced.
Table 11. Catch-A-Ride Program Successes and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|
Battle Creek Transit’s BCGo service is an on-demand microtransit service available throughout Calhoun County, MI, facilitating access to and from the rural areas of the county via an app-scheduled system. Much of the BCGo service area was previously without transit service. BCGo is highlighted as a case study due to its higher level of coordination with other local public and private stakeholders, which is expected to improve the sustainability of the service long-term.
The concept for the BCGo service was developed in 2019 by staff at Battle Creek Transit in partnership with two other local private transportation providers and Liftango as the technology partner. Initial funding was obtained via a MDOT grant that same year, though neither of the other transportation providers remained in place as service providers. As of this writing, the BCGo service continues to operate as a pilot program with two vehicles. The service plan calls for gradual expansion (once the concept is proven and funding is secured) to a fleet of 15–20 vehicles. Additionally, BCGo is part of a county-level initiative investigating the potential to create a transportation authority to better fund BCGo service—an effort that has already received support from MDOT because it helps that agency achieve its goals of expanding accessibility and improving efficiency. Long term, the BCGo team hopes to establish their platform, as developed by Liftango, as a licensable system that would allow any new city or other entity (e.g., transportation service providers or large employers) to get access to BCGo-type services. This concept is currently being tested in partnership with the City of Marshall, MI.
BCGo service is available from 6:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m. on weekdays and from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Saturdays. Fares vary according to the length of the trip requested and are presented to riders during the booking process (either via the service’s smartphone app or during a scheduling call with the customer service center), as shown in Table 12.
Table 12. Calhoun County Coordinated Mobility Pilot Fare Structure
| Miles of Trip | Fare |
|---|---|
| <6 miles | $3.00 |
| 6-10 miles | $5.00 |
| 11-15 miles | $7.00 |
| 16-20 miles | $10.00 |
| >20 miles | $15.00 |
| Additional passenger(s) | $3.00 |
Source: (BCGo, 2024)
BCGo uses Liftango software for trip scheduling and dispatching. Liftango also provides the customer-facing app used for trip requests/payments and the app that notifies drivers of trip assignments. Fare payments are handled during trip scheduling, with riders able to choose to pay via credit/debit card through the app and over the phone or to pay cash at the time of boarding (exact fare required).
Currently, the technology that powers BCGo does not integrate with other modes/services (such as Battle Creek’s fixed-route service) to facilitate transfers and fare payments.
BCGo uses small wheelchair-accessible passenger vans to provide service because these vehicles are viewed by their customers as providing higher quality/comfort compared to traditional small transit vehicles, as shown in Figure 13.
BCGo benefits from multiple partnerships that have contributed to the program’s success, as discussed in the following subsections.
MDOT funded the BCGo pilot since it was established in 2019 via a state grant.
Liftango is the technology partner for the BCGo service under a SaaS contract. In this role, the company is responsible for the following:
The City of Marshall is partnering with BCGo to license the BCGo system under a transportation service agreement. As part of this partnership, the same dispatch office/staff will be responsible for
City of Marshall trips, and the City will supply vehicles that will operate in the Marshall BCGo zone. The City has a portion of its property tax revenues dedicated to supporting transit. The system is set up to first allocate service capacity on Marshall vehicles to trips in the Marshall BCGo zone and, if there is excess capacity, assign these vehicles to other trips. According to the service agreement, service in Marshall will be implemented in phases as follows:
As of September 2023, the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners voted to create the Transportation Authority of Calhoun County (TACC) based on the success of the BCGo pilot. After TACC was approved, cities within the county voted internally on whether to opt out of the authority. Those cities that did not opt out were scheduled to participate in a subsequent vote about how much of their local property tax millage will be dedicated to TACC (Symonds, 2023).
BCGo service goals are summarized in Table 13. BCGo was designed to provide countywide transit service in areas with little or no existing service while improving mobility for historically underserved populations, improving overall service quality, and creating an alternative to traditional DRT. BCGo has found that a majority of users have household incomes under $50,000. Thirty-two percent of the users (the largest block) are between 25 and 40 years of age, but many students also use the service. Additionally, 60 percent of the service is requested by residents of higher density neighborhoods in or near the Battle Creek city boundaries. The only other similar transportation options available in the BCGo area are a service provided by a community action agency specifically to help older adults access medical care and a dial-a-ride service that is limited to the Battle Creek city limits.
Despite achieving outcomes that indicate progress toward BCGo’s goals, there have also been some challenges. High demand and rapid adoption of the service showed the agency that its understanding of needs within the community was accurate but also challenged the system by fueling some community sentiment that the service is not reliable (due to trips that cannot be accommodated as a result of the limited fleet size).
As with any new technology, there has been a learning curve for both riders and drivers, the biggest challenge being customer comfort with using the app to request trips instead of phone-based reservations. As of this writing, 70 percent of trip requests come through the app, but this required direct education about the service and the app via commercials and social media posts (e.g., the ability to schedule at any time of day instead of the 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. scheduling window for the call center). The agency has determined the remaining 30 percent of trip requests that continue to come through the call center to be riders without smartphones or with limited internet connectivity and older adults that prefer the social aspects of talking to someone to request a trip.
Table 13. BCGo Service Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Service Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops. | |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency. | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.). | ✔ |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations. | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.). | ✔ |
Operating BCGo service costs approximately $150,000 per vehicle, including overhead costs, per year. According to staff calculations, riders would have to pay $15 per person per ride for the service to break even. However, because a $15 fare would not be affordable for the majority of riders, a distance-based fare structure was adopted using a fare elasticity model developed by Calhoun County. When discussing service costs, both BCGo and MDOT acknowledge that transit of all kinds is a community investment, indicating that their agencies treat it as such by subsidizing service as much as possible. The staff also emphasized that a certain level of risk tolerance is required from funders when investing in new service.
Thus far, demand is higher than the service can accommodate partly because of limited driver availability. The union that represents Battle Creek Transit drivers has created a new job classification that does not require a CDL. This, combined with a shorter training period compared to traditional transit vehicle drivers (two weeks instead of six weeks), has helped BCGo more successfully recruit drivers. Additionally, Liftango is exploring methods for increasing efficiency of their trip assignment/routing system to address some of the issues that arise from demand that is higher than supply. While driver availability has been somewhat challenging, vehicle availability has not. The agency has been successful at getting vehicles through the Michigan vehicle schedule and has funding for capital purchases available from private entities that benefit from transit in their area (e.g., large employers including Kellogg and Firekeepers Casino).
BCGo service operates from 6:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m. on weekdays and from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Saturdays, but the highest service demand occurs between 7:00 and 9:00 a.m. and around 3:00 p.m. BCGo runs one vehicle in the morning and two in the afternoon.
As of this writing, riders are most critical of the current service capacity, stating that they want more service. Anecdotally, large employers in the service area have noted that their younger employees are more frequently reporting that they do not have access to a personal vehicle or a driver’s license, which seems to further drive already high demand from other demographics with high transportation needs. Beyond driver recruitment and system optimization efforts to improve service availability, BCGo has also implemented a feature that suggests the next possible time for a pickup if the requested pickup time is not available so that riders still have the choice to make the trip they requested.
Like many transit agencies in the last few years, Battle Creek Transit has experienced difficulties in recruiting and retaining drivers to operate vehicles in service (including those for BCGo). This has been related to the requirement of a CDL to operate the vehicles as well as the agency having a unionized work force. One remedy has been creating a non-CDL class of job that can operate the smaller BCGo vehicles; the agency has found that this increased its applicant pool for drivers tremendously.
All data generated from BCGo service are owned and controlled by Battle Creek Transit, as stipulated in the contract with Liftango. (There are no separate data agreements.) Liftango provides the data in a usable manner for the agency. Currently, data are presented in a Tableau reporting portal with unique dashboards that can be updated on demand with the most recent data. Liftango is also responsible for using the data to improve or optimize the system. BCGo dashboards include detailed information about service including but not limited to where requests are coming from (e.g., app versus customer service), origins and destinations, trip prices, vehicle capacity, and vehicle location. Data from these dashboards are regularly used in community presentations to share the success and describe the potential of the service. The BCGo app is also capable of surveying riders; through this feature, the agency has collected demographic data such as rider age and household income. All of the data the BCGo system has generated helped convince county leadership to pursue the TACC.
Broadband and cellular connectivity has not challenged the BCGo system. If connectivity for vehicle-based systems is temporarily reduced, the Liftango platform uses cached maps and rider manifests to continue uninterrupted until signal is restored. For users without access to the internet or smartphones, the BCGo call center offers an alternative that customers have been satisfied with to date.
The BCGo service was specifically designed and implemented to serve historically underserved riders with service anywhere in the county and be fully ADA accessible. To support access to service for cash payers, the system allows riders to request to pay cash (to be collected by drivers) at the time of reservation or use prepaid debit cards to either pay for a single trip or add stored funds in their BCGo account. However, discounted fares for people with low incomes, older adults, people with disabilities, and youth have not been implemented—something that could improve service accessibility. Similarly, BCGo is working to set up a system that would allow social service organizations or employers to pay fares on behalf of their clients via invoice.
For people that do not primarily speak English, the Liftango app is compatible with built-in smartphone language translation systems (though some languages, such as Burmese, are not yet available), which is one of the reasons the agency encourages users to request trips via the app (though the BCGo customer service phone line can provide translation support if needed). When BCGo launched, approximately 80 percent of riders requested trips via phone calls, but through direct education about the app and its benefits, the agency reduced this to 30 percent—an effort that helps maintain high-quality service for those that need the phone option while providing others with the additional flexibility and accessibility inherent to smartphone apps.
BCGo has not dealt with many liability or risk management issues beyond how to transport young riders. To address risks associated with transporting children BCGo implemented a policy that car seats are not permitted on vehicles and only children who are old/large enough to use lap and shoulder belts are allowed to ride on BCGo vehicles. This is a challenge noted by the agency as something that reduces the accessibility of the BCGo service since families with young children that would otherwise benefit from affordable transportation cannot ride.
The BCGo concept is inherently scalable and relatively low cost to operate, making a service like this a potential option for many rural, tribal, or frontier communities that lack comprehensive transit. The quick success of the program (and the latent needs that success highlighted) helped further the development of a new transportation authority that will provide a sustainable funding source for the service. Areas that have historically struggled with transit funding may be able to similarly leverage such a system. However, BCGo demand grew faster than supply, which led to some pushback about service quality and required additional agency effort to address; this is something to prepare for if adopting a similar system in high-need areas.
BCGo does not currently integrate with other modes or services or offer reduced fares. This is another an opportunity for other entities to improve on the BCGo service model.
Table 14 summarizes the key successes of the BCGo service and the key barriers that the service has faced.
Table 14. BCGo Service Success and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|
This case study includes information on two different but connected programs in North Carolina. The first is the upcoming Mobility for Everyone, Everywhere in North Carolina (MEE NC) program, which is anticipated to be implemented by early 2025 by NCDOT. The second is the RIDE microtransit service, which was implemented in 2020 in Wilson, NC. The RIDE service is adjacent to MEE NC but has helped inform the grant implementation for the upcoming program.
The project team recommended NCDOT’s MEE NC as a preferred case study option due to the level of state technical assistance and coordination with local transit agencies and the complexity of different provider and software vendors involved in the program.
NCDOT has partnerships with 11 participating communities to participate in the upcoming MEE NC program. Initial program funding will come from a Rural Surface Transportation Grant Program (RURAL) $10.4 million grant to NCDOT that can be used for capital expenses. The State of North Carolina is contributing $10 million to cover the local match requirements and some operating expenses. The RURAL grant-funded on-demand services within MEE NC will cater to the needs of each community for 36 months. MEE NC is characterized by two primary on-demand service models for microtransit (North Carolina Department of Transportation, 2024):
The 11 participating community systems were segmented into three tiers (North Carolina Department of Transportation, 2022):
For systems where it is not already available, call center assistance will be provided to allow citizens who do not have access to a smartphone or internet to book on-demand trips. On-demand service will be accessible to riders with disabilities as well as unbanked and underbanked riders (Bardaka, et al., 2023).
This section provides a summary of the partners involved or connected to the MEE NC program.
NCDOT serves as the Multimodal Project Discretionary Grant applicant and recipient responsible for administering grant money awarded. It is also responsible for awarding and contributing state matching funds, as required. NCDOT Integrated Mobility Division enters into agreements with each transit agency that contain any applicable “flow down” provisions from USDOT.
NCSU ITRE provides technical support to NCDOT and its programs, such as MEE NC. One prime example of this technical support is Public Microtransit Pilots in the State of North Carolina: Operational Characteristics, Costs, and Lessons Learned, which was relied upon significantly for this case study.
NCDOT aims for MEE NC to help communities throughout the state modernize transit service with on-demand mobility options, “leading to more mobility and improved access to opportunities, services, and resources” for residents (North Carolina Department of Transportation, 2024). At the time of this writing, the project grant agreement for MEE NC has been signed, and funding should start soon; NCDOT recently determined the program manager for MEE NC.
Prior to the MEE NC program, the City of Wilson served as a pilot case example to help inform NCDOT on implementation and operations learnings. The City replaced fixed-route service with an on-demand microtransit service called RIDE (Wilson, North Carolina, 2024). NCDOT views RIDE as a flagship program, both with respect to demonstrated ridership gains compared to previous service and low wait times for customer trip requests.
RIDE began in September 2020 after issues related to the COVID-19 pandemic made fixed-route service a challenge. RIDE serves an area greater than the previous fixed-route network, including the entire city boundary and some outlying employer destinations. A timeline of program development is shown in Figure 14, while Figure 15 shows the service area.
Service runs Monday through Friday 5:30 a.m.–7:00 p.m. and Saturday 7:00 a.m.–6:00 p.m. Scheduling takes place through an app, phone, or website, all three of which can also accommodate requests for WAVs; trips cannot be pre-scheduled before the day of service. Stops are primarily made curbside at intersections and at major destinations. The current average wait time is about 15–20 minutes.
Figure 16 shows how riders book RIDE trips. When a ride is booked in the app, an algorithm matches riders to vehicles, which are intended to provide quick, efficient, and shared trips with the least intrusions possible. The system uses “virtual bus stops,” but individuals with mobility issues get door-to-door service. Call center assistance is provided to allow customers who do not have access to a smartphone or internet to book on-demand trips.
As previously mentioned, scheduling takes place through an app, phone, or website. During the interview, the technology partner mentioned that (in their experience) creating pre-scheduled trips can create inefficiencies in the system. Having said that, it is understood that there is a subset of the population that needs to have the ability to pre-schedule trips (those with disabilities who may have a tough time scheduling return trips). Additionally, riders can pay using the app, cash, or ticket book (10 trips for $10).
Buggy provides vehicles, which are leased by individual drivers during their shift. RIDE has a current fleet size of about 20 vehicles, with four being wheelchair accessible. The maximum number of vehicles in operation at one time is 15. The City is hoping to add hybrid electric vehicles to its fleet, which will serve as a pilot project for the deployment of innovative and environmentally
sustainable vehicles for transit agencies across the state. The program is in the process of modernizing its fleet (due to mileage), so the fleet composition may be changing moving forward.
This section provides a summary of the partners involved in the RIDE service.
The City manages RIDE with two staff members overseeing transit. As such, it has a formal contract with Via for the technology platform, drivers, and, indirectly, vehicle procurement.
Via Transportation holds a contract with the City and provides the technology platform and drivers for RIDE. Via was awarded the work after presenting an unsolicited proposal to the City. The City used the contract template provided by Via itself.
Buggy holds a contract with Via to provide vehicles for RIDE. The vehicle drivers are Via contractors and lease vehicles from Buggy during their shift. The drivers are compensated for the lease cost.
RIDE program goals are summarized in Table 15. Prior to, as well as during, the initial months of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the City saw declining ridership on its fixed-route system and decided to replace it with a demand response service. Since RIDE’s inception, the City has been able to quadruple the number of transit trips and offer service throughout entire city jurisdiction; it has been able to do so while maintaining 15- to 20-minute wait times. Furthermore, by being able to provide a good service, the City believes RIDE has helped create a new process/culture of what transit means for residents. Additionally, the City noted that other communities see RIDE as an example of a service they might implement in their community.
RIDE also faces a few key challenges in operations, perhaps the most significant of which is driver shortages. The City has seen driver shortages and training requirements across the industry as a challenge to service. The vendor has tried to manage this by being more competitive with pay, but it remains an issue. The program has found it is important to have a fairly healthy driver pool and backlog of people who want to drive; this backlog has been developed through online marketing as well as word of mouth and referrals from current employees. Related to the driver shortage, supply chain issues have caused a slower than anticipated overhaul of the vehicle fleet with newer vehicles.
The availability of funding and cost of operations are also ever-present challenges. The City continues to look for funding wherever it can.
Finally, according to Public Microtransit Pilots in the State of North Carolina: Operational Characteristics, Costs, and Lessons Learned, “more than 60 percent of trips include a single passenger only.” Staff has seen this proportion decreased to about 50 percent; however, increasing passengers per vehicle is a key in maximizing cost efficiency for this type of service.
Table 15. RIDE Service Goals
| Common SUM Goals | Service Goals |
|---|---|
| First- and last-mile connections to fixed-route transit stops. | |
| Gap service in lower-density areas or during periods with low service frequency. | ✔ |
| Additional capacity for existing service (general public demand response, paratransit, etc.). | |
| Mobility for historically underserved populations. | ✔ |
| Improved service quality (reliability, scheduling, features, etc.). | ✔ |
For the contract period of October 2023 through September 2024, the City of Wilson will pay the contractor up to $1.6 million for RIDE. The program is currently being solely funded through local funds, although the funding stream was originally supplemented with federal (5311 Formula Grant for Rural Areas) and state (ConCPT) funds. It is anticipated that MEE NC federal funding will soon be available, as well as a $2 million earmark of federal dollars. Riders can pay for trips using the smartphone app, cash, or ticket book (10 trips for $10). A single trip costs $2.50, with additional passengers charged $1 per trip (a unique practice for group trip fare rates in general public microtransit).
The levels of federal/state versus local funding to support RIDE service have shifted over time. The City of Wilson does receive Section 5311 federal funding for administrative expenses as well as State Maintenance Assistance Program funding from NCDOT. At the beginning of the RIDE program the service was state and federally funded; some of those sources were not continued, and the funding mixture transitioned to around 90 percent locally funded. The local funding support for the microtransit service has helped make the implementation and deployment more plausible, though in the future it is likely that there will be a larger share of federal funding once again.
The City has seen that service demand and operational costs are directly correlated for this type of on-demand microtransit service, with increasing ridership characterized by increasing cost. The City has found that the key to maximizing efficiency with this type of service is to maximize ridership per vehicle. For instance, a small passenger vehicle transporting a single individual and a driver has the same operating costs as a six-person van transporting five passengers and a driver. However, the fare captured by the six-person van can be as much as five times that of the small passenger vehicle. It is difficult and perhaps improbable for the City to break even on the cost of RIDE service at the current fare rate for the service model.
Currently, staff believe that ridership for RIDE (estimated at more than 16,000 in June 2022) has plateaued, which may make it difficult for the service to meet increased demand without securing additional funding.
Table 16 provides some dated key metrics pulled from the NCSU ITRE report (Bardaka, et al., 2023).
Table 16. RIDE Operating Costs and Statistics
| Statistic | Value |
|---|---|
| Fiscal year period | 7/1/2021 to 6/30/2022 |
| Operating cost | $1,609,052 |
| Operating days | 313 |
| Vehicle revenue hours | 22,065 |
| Vehicle revenue miles | 315,409 |
| Total ridership | 156,887 |
| Average monthly ridership | 13,074 |
| Latest monthly ridership (June 2022) | 16,243 |
| Cost per operating day | $5,141 |
| Cost per vehicle revenue hour | $72.92 |
| Cost per vehicle revenue mile | $5.10 |
| Cost per passenger | $10.26 |
Source: (Bardaka, et al., 2023)
The City sees clear a.m. and p.m. peaks in service demand that align with riders using the service to get to and from work. Statistics suggesting that RIDE is successful in meeting mobility needs were captured in a 2021 Customer Satisfaction Survey (development, administration, and analysis done by the contractor). Some of the key findings are presented here (Bardaka, et al., 2023):
While riders have praised the service, there have also been suggestions regarding areas where they would like to see service improvements. Riders report wanting shorter wait times and expanded hours of service.
The current RIDE fleet size is about 20 vehicles, with four being WAVs. The maximum number of vehicles in operation at one time is 15. Even as the fleet is being modernized and composition of vehicle types is possibly changing in the near future, supply chain issues have reduced the speed at which the contractor has been able to modernize its fleet. Also, driver shortages remain a challenge to RIDE services.
In the agreement for RIDE service, the contracted vendor currently owns the data. Per the contract with the City, the vendor produces a dashboard for the City showing key metrics; this dashboard is updated by the vendor on a weekly basis. Staff has found it difficult to obtain detailed origin/destination data beyond the basic ridership data in the dashboard metrics. While the current contract agreement with the technology vendor meets FTA requirements, the City would like to add in additional stipulations such as those regarding data ownership, accident reporting, and vehicle inspection requirements.
One of the key performance measurement aspects for RIDE service is that the operational costs of on-demand microtransit services are positively and directly correlated to ridership. As requests for the service increases, so too does the need for additional resources, such as vehicle and drivers. Because of the typical single rider per trip nature of on-demand service, the cost is more sensitive to demand than fixed-route service, where large transit vehicles transport multiple fare paying riders at a time. To make this service cost-effective, it is imperative to maximize (to the extent possible) shared rides. However, given present levels of demand it is not possible to increase shared rides in service scheduling further because other service quality goals would be violated (e.g., on-time performance).
The City owns and operates a fiber broadband network (Greenlight) across the city; any resident can sign up for data packages at monthly rates that start with up to 1 gigabit speeds (Greenlight Community Broadband, 2024). Additionally, the whole community has access to free public Wi-Fi through the city’s Greenlight Community Broadband project, which has several access points available within the city limits (Wilson, North Carolina, 2020). As such, connectivity (including cellular) has not been an issue.
The City reported making slight adjustments regarding accessibility. One such adjustment was providing, by default, a WAV to any person with a disability that requested a trip on RIDE service. There have been instances where an individual with a visual impairment has requested a trip, could use a non-WAV, and did not want to take a WAV away from someone that might need it more. In these instances, the rider will have a non-WAV dispatched to them.
Similarly, some people with disabilities need door-to-door service but do not require a WAV and do not want to tie them up. The solution was for these riders to call the customer service line and let them know they do not need a WAV but still need door-to-door service.
The City reported having no insurance-related liability issues.
It is plausible that without the support of NCDOT, RIDE might never have gotten off the ground. However, given the strong framework developed by the City combined with the knowledge gained through lessons learned, a similar service might be deployed in other areas.
As a small city in a rural community, there are still several challenges present to maintain RIDE service. However, their deleterious effects can be mitigated through keeping an eye on upcoming federal funding opportunities through grants and other FTA funding mechanisms, the application of driver recruitment mechanisms (such as looking to partner with companies who give their employees time off so they may serve as contracted drivers), and the application of innovative marketing and pricing strategies aimed at increasing passengers per vehicle trip.
Table 17 summarizes the key successes of the RIDE service and the key barriers that the service has faced.
Table 17. RIDE Service Successes and Barriers
| Successes | Barriers |
|---|---|
|
|