This appendix contains a detailed explanation of how the literature searches were performed for each vaccine and adverse event reviewed by the committee. The searches were performed by William Mcleod, Senior Research Librarian at the National Academies.
DESCRIPTION OF THE DATABASES USED
IN THE LITERATURE SEARCH
All searches were run against MEDLINE (1950–present), EMBASE (1980–present), BIOSIS (1969–2005), and Web of Science consisting of Science Citation Index (1900–present) and Social Science Citation Index (1956–present). There were no restrictions placed on year of publication, language, or publication type. All result sets were deduplicated to eliminate occurrence of the same reference two or more times among the databases employed, and all results were exported to an EndNote Library.
MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
OVID command-line syntax is provided below. Terms immediately followed by a forward slash (/) are Medical Subject Headings (MeSH headings from MEDLINE) or EMTREE terms (from the EMBASE controlled vocabulary). The asterisk after some terms (*) is the OVID unlimited truncation symbol (for example, rat*, will retrieve rat, rats, ratify, rational, etc.). The postqualification .ti,ab. means that a term was searched only in the titles and abstracts. Exp means that a term was “exploded” in the MeSH
or EMTREE vocabulary to also capture all narrower terms associated with the broader concept.
BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of Science (Science
Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
All BIOSIS search terms were submitted to the database using keyword or keyword-phrase searches and were not qualified or limited to a specific field. In OVID SP BIOSIS, when a search term is not qualified, it is automatically searched in the following fields: abstract; biosystematic code; book title; chemicals and biochemicals; concept codes; diseases; gene name; major concepts; miscellaneous descriptors; methods and equipment; organisms; parts, structure; sequence data; super taxa; titles; taxa notes; text words; heading words; subject headings; and meeting information.
All Web of Science searches were submitted to the databases as topic searches that automatically search titles, abstracts, and author-supplied keywords.
MEASLES, MUMPS, AND RUBELLA VACCINE
Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine Searches in
MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with four “base sets” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
Each set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
disintegrative disorder/ or pervasive development disorder not otherwise specified/
Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine Searches in
BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of Science (Science
Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with four “base sets” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
Each set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
syndrome” or “opsoclonus myoclonus ataxia” or “Kinsbourne syndrome”)
VARICELLA VACCINE
Varicella Vaccine Searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Varicella vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
Varicella Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of
Science (Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Varicella vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
INFLUENZA VACCINE
Influenza Vaccine Searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Influenza vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
Influenza Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of Science (Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Influenza vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
HEPATITIS A VACCINE
Hepatitis A Vaccine Searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Hepatitis A vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
Hepatitis A Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of
Science (Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Hepatitis A vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
HEPATITIS B VACCINE
Hepatitis B Vaccine Searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Hepatitis B vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair result-
ing from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
Hepatitis B Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of
Science (Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Hepatitis B vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
HUMAN PAPILLOMAVIRUS VACCINE
Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccine Searches in
MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
HPV vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
HPV Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of Science
(Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
HPV vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
DIPHTHERIA TOXOID–, TETANUS TOXOID–, AND
ACELLULAR PERTUSSIS–CONTAINING VACCINES
Diphtheria Toxoid (DT)–, Tetanus Toxoid (TT)–, and
Acellular Pertussis (aP)–Containing Vaccine Searches
in MEDLINE and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
DT–, TT–, and aP–containing vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
grative disorder/ or pervasive development disorder not otherwise specified/
DT–, TT–, and aP–Containing Vaccine Searches in
BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of Science (Science
Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
DT–, TT–, and aP–containing vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
MENINGOCOCCAL VACCINE
Meningococcal Vaccine Searches in MEDLINE
and EMBASE (in OVID SP)
Meningococcal vaccine searches in MEDLINE and EMBASE started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair resulting from this combination was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library:
Meningococcal Vaccine Searches in BIOSIS (in OVID SP) and Web of
Science (Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index)
Meningococcal vaccine searches in BIOSIS and Web of Science started with one “base set” with which all specific adverse events identified for consideration were combined:
The set above was combined with each of the sets below. Each pair was deduplicated, when the online database provided this utility, and then exported to an EndNote library: