This chapter introduces the study. First, background information is provided about low-income fare discounts. Next, the objectives of the study are presented. Then, the technical approach used to carry out the study is described. Finally, the structure of the report is summarized.
According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, 13% of American households have an annual household income of less than $15,000, but 21% of transit-using households have an annual household income of less than $15,000 (APTA 2017). Moreover, income levels of transit users vary in different regions and cities of different sizes. For example, 48% of riders in the smallest cities (by population) report household income levels of less than $15,000 per year, whereas in the largest cities, only 20% of riders report household incomes of less than $15,000 per year (APTA 2017). Making transit fares affordable is important to providing access to these low-income riders.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic, many transit agencies have put more energy and resources into enhancing access for all riders in their communities, particularly low-income riders. Transit agencies have pursued strategies to increase the affordability of transit services, including introducing or expanding free or reduced-fare policies. Some transit agencies have begun to offer low-income fare discount programs that provide direct subsidies to riders with the greatest financial need. Eligibility for participation in these programs is based either on a specified income threshold or prior qualification in another state or federal welfare program. This means-based strategy typically offers low-income riders transit fares discounted by a percentage off the full fare price, a reduced price for fare capping, a specified number of free rides, discounted period passes, or a combination of these (Rosenblum et al. 2019, Darling et al. 2021, Brough et al. 2022).
The implementation of these fare discount programs has yielded predominantly positive outcomes in that they facilitate travel by low-income individuals. Research suggests that implementation of low-income fare discount programs has increased transit use by low-income individuals to access destinations like work, education, and healthcare (Thistle and Paget-Seekins 2017, Rosenblum et al. 2019, Brough et al. 2022). In addition, some research has found increases in transit use by low-income individuals during off-peak periods and on less heavily traveled routes, indicating that these ridership gains may fill in available space on transit rather than adding to already congested times and routes (Rosenblum et al. 2019, Brough et al. 2022). This study provides a synthesis of current practices related to low-income fare discount programs and their implementation at transit agencies across the United States and Canada to help inform transit agencies interested in implementing a new low-income fare discount program or enhancing an existing program.
With the growing implementation of low-income fare discount programs over the last decade (Darling et al. 2021), this study aims to synthesize information on how these programs are administered by transit agencies and their partner organizations in the United States and Canada. The study considers numerous aspects of low-income fare discount programs, including the discount structure and amount; the enrollment process and eligibility criteria; technology and fare media; costs to administer, estimated fare revenue forgone, and funding sources; program administration, program operations, and regional collaboration; and performance measures and outcomes.
The technical approach for this study included a review of the literature pertaining to low-income fare discounts, an online survey of transit agencies and operators that participate in a low-income fare discount program in the United States and Canada, and development of detailed case examples based on teleconference interviews with representatives from seven transit agencies. The online survey included more than 60 questions on various aspects of low-income fare discount programs, including program administration, regional collaboration, costs, performance measures, and lessons learned. Twenty-six responses were received.
This study is organized as follows.