At its first meeting, February 3–4, 1994, the committee divided itself into three panels (see Table B-1). The panels were each assigned different tasks that, taken together, addressed the committee's full statement of task. The panels operated from the first committee meeting until January 30, 1995, each providing written material that was used as a basis for the committee's report. The panels met separately from the full committee as required, often coordinating their meetings with full committee meetings (see Appendix C). The committee Chair, Dale Stein, and Vice-Chair, Gregory Choppin, provided guidance to all three panels.
The Decision and Process Analysis Panel was staffed by Tracy Wilson, Board on Energy and Environmental Systems (BEES); the Technology Panel was staffed by Douglas Raber, Board on Chemical Sciences and Technology (BCST), Scott Weidman of BCST, and Jill Wilson of BEES; and the Cost Analysis Panel was staffed by Karyanil Thomas, Board on Radioactive Waste Management. James Zucchetto, Study Director, worked with the panels as necessary and, together with Jill Wilson and Tracy Wilson, worked with the committee to produce its final report. Dev Mani, Director of BEES, and Richard Meserve, Vice-Chair of BEES, provided board oversight for the entire study.
TABLE B-1 Committee Panels and Membership
|
Decision and Process Analysis |
Technology |
Cost Analysis |
|
Elisabeth Pate-Cornella |
William Prindlea |
Frank Crimia |
|
Eula Bingham |
Joseph Byrd |
Charles Kimm |
|
Joel Cehn |
Robert Connick |
Peter Lederman |
|
Philip Clark |
Bernd Kahn |
Geoffrey Rothwell |
|
Wolter Fabrycky |
Peter Lederman |
Ray Sandberg |
|
Robert Fjeld |
Walter May |
Richard Smith |
|
Alvin Mushkatel |
Alfred Schneider |
|
|
Carolyn Raffensperger |
|
|
|
a Panel chair |
||
The statement of tasks formulated by the committee for the panels are discussed below.
The Decision and Process Analysis Panel will develop a framework for the decontamination and decommissioning (D&D) of the gaseous diffusion plants (GDPs) and will address the following subjects:
The Technology Panel will identify and evaluate technical processes of importance to the D&D of the GDPs and the stockpile of depleted uranium hexafluoride (DUF6). Its investigation will include the following:
The panel will study these issues as they relate to the D&D of GDPs:
For the DUF6, the panel will consider two areas:
The Cost Analysis Panel will undertake the following:
Other activities will include review of costs incurred on completed D&D projects. Alternative approaches to effect reductions in cost will be examined.