Skip to main content

Rethinking Researcher Assessment and Incentives at U.S. Academic Institutions: A Workshop

Recently completed

A committee-supported project or activity that has been completed and for which output dissemination has begun. Its committee has been disbanded and closeout procedures are underway.

This National Academies workshop will explore new approaches to expand the criteria for which researchers are assessed at U.S. academic institutions beyond traditional outputs such as grants, publications, and citation counts. The workshop will bring together professors, researchers, and administrators to explore effective strategies for implementing these changes at universities across the U.S.

Description

A planning committee of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine will organize a workshop to examine avenues for broadening the current criteria for researcher assessment and incentives within U.S. academic institutions beyond traditional research outputs such as grants, publications, and citation counts. The workshop will focus on expanding researcher assessment of and incentives for activities that contribute broadly to U.S. research and scientific leadership, such as the following:

  • Contributing to open access publishing and data sharing;
  • Enhancing research transparency and strengthening research integrity;
  • Engaging the community in research and addressing local, societal, and regulatory needs;
  • Conducting research-centered mentorship for early career researchers; and
  • Fostering team science and interdisciplinary collaborations.

The workshop will examine case studies of institutions that have adopted or are piloting expanded researcher assessment criteria in ways that have the potential to transform reward systems and advancement policies at U.S. academic institutions. The workshop will bring together researchers and university administrators to explore effective strategies for implementing these potential assessment changes at scale. A Proceedings in Brief will be published following the workshop.

Collaborators

Committee

Mitul Luhar

Co-Chair

Julie Risien

Co-Chair

Almesha L. Campbell

Member

Liesl Folks

Member

Pramod P. Khargonekar

Member

Veronique Kiermer

Member

Emily Pentzer

Member

Eri Saikawa

Member

Alison Boland-Reeves

Staff Officer

Sarah Rovito

Staff Officer

Sponsors

Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation

Staff

Sarah Rovito

Lead

SRovito@nas.edu

Alison Boland-Reeves

ABolandReeves@nas.edu

Komal Syed

KSyed@nas.edu

Jordan Graves

JGraves@nas.edu

Beau Nielsen

ANielsen@nas.edu

Karla Riley

KRiley@nas.edu

Subscribe to Email from the National Academies
Keep up with all of the activities, publications, and events by subscribing to free updates by email.