In your role, you will need to look outside of yourself and typical team members to truly understand a decision, particularly a decision in an area in which you do not have a lot of experience. Plan for this by creating a system to ensure collaboration with the people who will be most impacted, are often ignored, and who will offer honest assessments on the topic. Challenge conventional data and strategies in order to stimulate innovation.
The text in the infographic reads as follows:
1. Include More Voices: Extend conversations surrounding the decision into groups that will be most affected or have historically been left out.
2. Don’t Automatically Accept the Norm: Research data and methods used in other sectors to identify innovative and better solutions.
3. Get Candid Critiques: Understand that candor may only come when you are removed from the discussion. Provide the space to get honesty.
Welcoming more input from diverse audiences and sources can help unlock potential benefits:
Seek diverse input at the outset of any major decision. This includes individuals or groups with technical expertise as well those who are particularly familiar with a key group of stakeholders; those who have a strong understanding of relevant history; experts on legal, regulatory, and other requirements; those who can help you to effectively communicate throughout the decision-making process; and representatives of conflicting perspectives on the issue.
Never have just one person talking to you about an issue.
—Joyce Taylor
Chief Engineer, Maine DOT
A specific way to ensure that multiple perspectives are considered is to intentionally include voices from those groups that will be most affected by the decision or that have historically been
left out of major decision-making in transportation. This is especially important if the decision will disproportionately affect a specific group or community. Including these voices can transform perceptions of the decision from something happening to the affected group to something happening with them and lead to an outcome that reflects those voices from affected groups.
Industry partners in particular—or anyone with a monetary or other interest in your good opinion—may be hesitant to provide frank opinions to you directly. However, honest feedback is essential for making informed and unbiased decisions. Consider assigning someone other than yourself to gauge the temperature of impending decisions and garner sincere reactions from those who may sugarcoat information directly to you.
Watch out for people who will tell you what you want to hear. Ask around for who will give you honest information.
—Russell McMurry
Commissioner, Georgia DOT
Identify confidantes within and outside of the organization who sit in a different place than you do in terms of background, expertise, or perspective. Select individuals within the agency as well as outside voices who have been where you presently are to help provide guidance.
Read content from across disciplines and encourage your staff to as well. This will help you to ask relevant questions and get everyone thinking more broadly than their default perspective. Stay up to date on industry news and have key team members stay on top of news in their areas, so they are always prepared to talk through issues as robustly as possible. When an issue touches a discipline you or your team are less familiar with, do a high-level review of that area to learn the basics about how it might affect the issue at hand.
Evaluate additional data sources from nontraditional outlets when possible. Avoid relying solely on conventional partners and information simply because they are tried and true. Discover new applications for existing data from other sectors, particularly if the other data have advantages such as easy access or timeliness. For example, data from hospital emergency departments can be leveraged in crash analyses, as the data-monitoring programs in emergency departments do not suffer from the data lag issues that plague police reports. Such data also provide an expanded sample size that can lead to more insightful crash evaluations.
Your leadership position requires you to consider the global impacts of decisions, that is, how your decision will affect everything at once, not just one particular area. Mentally pull back from the decisionʼs minutiae to assess where else impacts of the decision might be felt and bring this into the decision-making calculus.